Fans of the Twilight series are notorious for their obsessive and sometimes blind adoration of the books and films. Bella Should Have Dumped Edward: Controversial Views on the Twilight Series, on the other hand, takes the viewpoints of fans on a number of hot topic discussion points, including who the lead, Bella Swan, should have ended up with, and if werewolf imprinting in the series is moral and just. There is debate on all the subjects, and the fans come off as remarkably well-thought and intuitive. If someone is adamant about an opinion, there is usually a reason behind it. Sometimes it is fair and just, and understandable, other times it may be a bit far-fetched (is imprinting really romantic, especially when it's a small child and teenage boy?).

The final question of the debate is if the comparison of the Twilight series to that of Harry Potter in mass media is misguided. The fans whose answers were recorded in the book were unanimous in feeling that both series are significantly different, and it is pointless to compare the two. Just because they are both fantasies and contain mythical creatures, all of whom are teenagers, does not make them one in the same. Nor are the similar, as the fans state, because they have actors who starred in both.

Overall, the author found most intelligible answers to questions that have been asked from the fans and Twilight naysayers, and answered with poise - for the most part - and with justification.

Bella Should Have Dumped Edward: Controversial Views on the Twilight Series can be ordered here at Amazon.com and Amazon.co.uk.