That Guardian guy sounds like a snobbish curmudgeon! I like some of the comments bashing him though. The other reviews released so far have been better, such as the Telegraph and IGN. Some Australian reviewer criticized the "awful knits" they wore while camping, and thought the two movies should have been condensed into one as it was too long (obviously not a fan). I'm curious about how the American reviewers will view it - they seem a little more laid back. Not that it will matter - the movie will make millions. Can't wait for 11/19!