View Single Post
Old 11-05-2010, 07:03 PM   #273 (permalink)
Connie
Gryffindor
Puffskein
 
Connie's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Florida
Posts: 1,415

Hogwarts RPG Name:
Janet Lynn Gordon
Fifth Year
Default
Werecats are people too! Reader of Fan Fictions

Hello Katie girl!
Quote:
and what an end it was! It was the best! Your ideas were ingenious and everything fit together so well. JK would be so proud of you! But, since she’s not here, I will have to congratulate you for her.
Thank you sweetie. You are too kind to say that, and all the sweet things you say clear throughout your comment.
Quote:
I love how you were effortlessly able to incorporate JK into your Epilogue.
I hope she doesn't mind.
Quote:
One question though... what kind of doughnut was it? That was one small detail you really should've included!
Awe Man! I knew there would be at least one thing I forgot! I can't say for sure, because I've only just read her saying doughnut. But, as she was tight on money, I assume it was just a glazed one. Yummy. I love glazed doughnuts when they are fresh made. Thanks a lot Katie! Now I'm slobbering all over myself wanting a doughnut!
Quote:
I also liked the concept of good versus evil. You’re right, you know... the children of today seem to have a hard time grasping the concept: whether due to peer pressure, ignorance or simple stupidity. Well done again!
My hope and desire is that our young people all over the world will stop and try to see things in a different way, and see if they can reason out a better way out of bad situations, instead of thinking all is lost and just join a gang to be eccepted. Thank you Katie.
Quote:
I loved how you were able to explain away the recovery of Dumbledore’s memories by comparing it to the return of Harry’s at the time of Dumbledore’s death.
Thanks. It's what made sense to me. I wasn't happy that spells and curses just wore off in the 5th book when the kids were fighting in the Ministry of Magik. But, when Harry became able to move again after Dumbledore fell over the tower, I thought Harrys reasoning made sense, so I used the same reasoning.
Quote:
I loved that Crookshanks finally found a place to stay to await his impending death. It was perfect ending to your story Connie. The poor boy/cat deserved a peaceful, loving and happy ending to his rather hard yet adventurous life. Thank you for thinking of that.
He was my favorite character, and I wanted him to be able to be with someone he didn't have to keep his cat side or human side, whichever way you look at it, a secret. He can be himself.
Quote:
Now... the title meaning... I find it rather intriguing and can argue the pros and cons of each. You have truly created a title that aptly describes and enhances the story. Well done my friend. Your story has been well thought out and planned right down to the smallest detail.

Connie, I’m so sorry that your Fan Fiction has come to an end, but I guess it is only right that it does and that it ends on such a successful note. Thank you for your time and for sharing your wisdom and love of writing with us.
Thank you so much. I love it when titles have everything to do with the story. Thank you so much for everything. Your comments have humbled me. I was blessed to have wounderful readers, and I always enjoyed your comments.
Connie is offline