Oh.


Patroclus was good at Vanishing, but re-conjouring was a little beyond his four years of education.
He was perfect at Evanesco, an OWL level spell, due to the fact that his mother was former Transgifuration professor at Beauxbatons, but usually his mother returned his vanished items.......but Pandora wasn't her right now.

Patroclus had been expecting that something would have happened to bring them all back, but Oppps.....

"Professor, I agree with Kurumi," he smiled. "Each person has a different take on the riddle, some may want to use magic, some may want to just use their hands, everything is personal......." then in a hushed tone. "Professor, I can't get my cookie back"

Cue sweet smile!