Nymphy was pretty much on board, but wanted o be in the loop so he made up a question. It was not one that really had a defnite answer, but was meant more to make the professor and others think.....

He raised his hand and asked, "Yes, Professor Dudson. How can one appraoch Herbology in forensics and Auror-ship in a balanced way.....I mean to say, in Herbology, the plant is both the poison and the antidote, the gun and the shield, the weapon and the defense. How does one differentiat and make desisive decisions in such a complex field." he said, proud of his question. However, he realized that it may be a bit much for one question....so he amended "That is to say, that was a lot to handle in one question. I guess it was made just to be considered as a braod topic rather than receive a specific answer......"

Nymphy put his hand down and looked inquisitvly at his Professor, hoping that he had impressed him, without offending or confusing him.