 SS Featured AuthorTürk Bilgini Bugbear
Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: {in a leap of faith}
Posts: 31,791
Hogwarts RPG Name: Sarani Glass Graduated x12
| House-elves happy with the way things are. {Post # 2} ♥ Mrs. Itachi Uchiha™ & MAJNOO! : Bleach & Kyo & Natsume ♥ [ Maxh!Jesh ] Quote:
Originally Posted by She-Who-Is-Not-To-Be-Psycho! Diane listened and watched as other student took the podium stating their reasoning. Since none of the options reflected what she herself thought, maybe she should choose the one that came the closest. After all, it was not a subject she had any intention of being parcial about. Plus, few of them had seemed to share it; that made her choice all the more original.
Thus, when no one took the podium for a while, Diane rose up and, moved to the front. She had no notes with her, and did not seem nervous. "Ehem," she cleared her throat, in the way people usually did when they wanted to get people's attention. Her doing it, though, sounded like mocking those people.
"My group," she began, "S.P.E.W.," she clarified, "has taken the wrong steps in the past. It is as you say, we have not been mindful of what house-elves alledgely want. But we wonder if you are in a position to say you know what their desires are. We wonder what are the undelying intentions in wanting to keep the status quo. We wonder if maybe you are a bit too comfortable with the current accomodations. In other words, we question your good intentions.
"Yes, we have been criticized in the past," she went on, "But it's, nonetheless, a group that has no personal sinister agenda to change social order," again, she put a mock sort of grim tone when she spoke, "but merely wishes to provide for their best interest. Our stand is simple. If you want to take care of your elves, then serve them back."
Cue plain and cute smile. Podium time again. Fyo had been listening closely to the ongoing debates, clearly interested. His ears perked up as Diane began to speak - intelligent girl there. He listened attentively, something she said especially catching his attention.
"Diane," he began. "You have said that S.P.E.W merely wishes to provide for the best interest of house-elves and, although I do not doubt that the intentions of the group you represent are good, I would like to ask how you can be so sure that you are, indeed, taking the correct measures to ensure that house-elves are treated properly."
Time to explain what he was trying to say, maybe? "Hermione Granger, founder of S.P.E.W, is known for having freed house-elves by hiding hats and socks in her common room. We also know that, when Ronald Weasley came to know of this, he made sure the house-elves knew what they were picking before they picked it. That way, he gave the house-elves a choice between servitude and freedom, which resulted in two things: one, not a single house-elf chose to free him- or herself; and two, the house-elves of Hogwarts stopped cleaning the Gryffindor common room because the "clothes" offended them. This proves, beyond doubt, that house-elves like to work, and are offended by any thought contrary."
He paused for a breath of air, glad with the way that last point of his had turned out. It was something supported by historical evidence, and he liked backing his say by proof. Anyway, back to the audience now, no?
"I would like to continue with a point I stressed earlier - that Dobby was an exception, and we can not base our treatment of an entire race on a single exception. One may say that some house-elves do not choose freedom because they have already been so oppressed by the Wizarding family they serve, that they have no will of their own left. But the above-mentioned facts make it clear that house-elves feel the same way about freedom, even if they are not oppressed into thinking that servitude is the purpose of their lives - The Hogwarts of Albus Dumbledore's time provided a good environment to its house-elves, and when Hermione Granger began knitting things for them, they had absolute freedom to make a choice in the favour of not working, but none of them made it."
He needed to stop rambling. But there was just so much he had to say on this subject! Fyo paused finally, this time for several seconds. He had a feeling he had just crashed his Shy!Shell for good and proper, but he would think of that later. HappyHappyYAY house-elves, for now. OOC: To be continued.
Last edited by Maxilocks; 08-09-2009 at 04:07 PM.
Reason: Forgot to add "to be continued" ^^
|