"Well, I say we let him come to the department and see what happens," Samantha said. "Perhaps he will be happier in a different environment. As I said, my department is very involved in a very extensive project at the moment and I would not mind the extra help right now. That will be the true test, I would say. Since J.J. has been so anxious to come to my department, I say we do this. J.J. has brought a lot of things to my attention, including the students who were turning into animals at Hogwarts last term and also the recent murders that have been happening with various students' families. Perhaps there is something he can offer to my department, and might make him better suited to come there, after all. One never knows where one's true interest lies, and everyone deserves a second chance. I am willing to give that chance."