It's not an issue of "who is the better person" and "may the best one win"; the issue is if the Lexicon infringes upon JKR's copyright laws.
And I think it does.
So, to set a precedent for other authors, this could be considered a landmark case. Especially if you notice this:
Quote:
If she loses the case, Ms. Rowling said on Wednesday, "the floodgates will open," and writers everywhere will lose control of their material. "Are we the owners of our own work?"
Very good point. Kinda makes me nervous, as a fan-fic writer too.