Originally Posted by Phoenixis

"Very young but talented in one area... It happens but not quite often... Wait what if the spell was never his?" Piper asked.

Originally Posted by bonnelass830

Shai peered over at the file, "Well it says he's eager to leave his mark on the wizarding world, which isn't always the best reason to create a charm. And like you pointed out, just because one is gifted at producing charms, doesn't mean they are gifted at creating them. What I think so far is that we'd need a fuller testimony from his charms teacher, to see if he ever tried creating charms or seemed interested in such things while he was in school. Perhaps talk to one or two more of his teachers and see what kind of student he was like in their classes, you know, to see if we can corroborate the ex girlfriend's statements. We have two differing opinions, but with something common...the ex says he was a slacker, the teacher says he wasn't gifted in much else. They aren't the same thing, but they're similar." Shai stopped for a moment to think.