SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post

caseym · 02-26-2008, 06:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phoenixis

"Well that would make her testimony not so reliable... I mean the girl was using all sort of lies maybe to get into detention... But if she really liked Newman and she was all of the bad boys types doesn't that make Newman not more reliable than she is... I mean maybe the reason after Newman's creation of the spell was to hurt someone not cure blemishes." Piper said.

"Well, we don't know about the lies and such, but what we do know is that we can't really believe anything she says about him due to the fact that her background isn't quite clear. Now, she could have been telling the truth about him, but we don't know much about his character from this." She flipped to the other testimony, "Gladys Victorla, 67, taught Benji at Hogwarts and said he was gifted in charms, but not much else. However, she has also said he always completed homework for her class. Adding this statement on to what we know of the previous statement, what can you infer?"

02-26-2008, 06:54 PM	#68 (permalink)
caseym Baffling Bella Brand New Car! Snidget Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: PM if you wanna RP! Posts: 2,767 Hogwarts RPG Name: Brianna Lynn Bunch First Year	Quote: Originally Posted by Phoenixis "Well that would make her testimony not so reliable... I mean the girl was using all sort of lies maybe to get into detention... But if she really liked Newman and she was all of the bad boys types doesn't that make Newman not more reliable than she is... I mean maybe the reason after Newman's creation of the spell was to hurt someone not cure blemishes." Piper said. "Well, we don't know about the lies and such, but what we do know is that we can't really believe anything she says about him due to the fact that her background isn't quite clear. Now, she could have been telling the truth about him, but we don't know much about his character from this." She flipped to the other testimony, "Gladys Victorla, 67, taught Benji at Hogwarts and said he was gifted in charms, but not much else. However, she has also said he always completed homework for her class. Adding this statement on to what we know of the previous statement, what can you infer?" __________________