SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post

caseym · 02-25-2008, 02:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phoenixis

"Well... For starters I think that this spell must be denied" Piper started to explain. "One because it uses living beings, the downfall of such charms is that the charm might backfire and cause the animal to get hurt or worse it's death... My illusion charm was going to get denied because of that... Two, if the charm does work properly, the animal might get in contact with muggles and cause exposure... Which I don't think the wizard community might accept... So in my opinion such spell even if it has many advantages must be denied..." Piper finished hoping that this was the answer her boss was looking for.

Brianna nodded, "Yes, those reasons alone are enough to warrant the denial of this charm." She paused, then added, "Not only that, but the fact that an animal can speak wouldn't change its normal habits. So while this may work on domesticated animals, though I'm pretty sure we wouldn't want to know what they have to say, it wouldn't work on wild animals. Wild animals would still be fearful and naturally would want to stay as far from us as possible, and giving them the power of speech wouldn't change that." She sat up, leaning back towards her desk, "That one is definitely getting denied, good job, Piper." She smiled at her new employee, glad that someone so bright was in this position.

02-25-2008, 02:03 PM	#51 (permalink)
caseym Baffling Bella Brand New Car! Snidget Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: PM if you wanna RP! Posts: 2,767 Hogwarts RPG Name: Brianna Lynn Bunch First Year	Quote: Originally Posted by Phoenixis "Well... For starters I think that this spell must be denied" Piper started to explain. "One because it uses living beings, the downfall of such charms is that the charm might backfire and cause the animal to get hurt or worse it's death... My illusion charm was going to get denied because of that... Two, if the charm does work properly, the animal might get in contact with muggles and cause exposure... Which I don't think the wizard community might accept... So in my opinion such spell even if it has many advantages must be denied..." Piper finished hoping that this was the answer her boss was looking for. Brianna nodded, "Yes, those reasons alone are enough to warrant the denial of this charm." She paused, then added, "Not only that, but the fact that an animal can speak wouldn't change its normal habits. So while this may work on domesticated animals, though I'm pretty sure we wouldn't want to know what they have to say, it wouldn't work on wild animals. Wild animals would still be fearful and naturally would want to stay as far from us as possible, and giving them the power of speech wouldn't change that." She sat up, leaning back towards her desk, "That one is definitely getting denied, good job, Piper." She smiled at her new employee, glad that someone so bright was in this position. __________________