SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post - DADA Lesson 2

lazykitty · 06-08-2019, 01:02 PM

Pot stirring? Yes please. In her opinion, there were TOO MANY people who were afraid of doing so in the wizarding world right now, which made for a very boring time for all. So, bring on the pot stirring. And in that spirit....

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nordic Witch

After a short breath Ellie added "Um, I think you're also seen as a dark wizard by the public if you illegally breed dark creatures." Other than that she didn’t know what to contribute to what everyone else was already saying.

"By that logic, Rubeus Hagrid would be a dark wizard," she began with a chuckle, "thanks to his Blast-Ended Skrewts. Not to mention his half-giant status. Also, Professor O'Hara and her family, since she's part-goblin." And she didn't think anyone would call either of them dark, especially not Hagrid. I mean, the guy was loyal to Harry Potter to the very end!

Now, for the whole killing debate. Yes, killing people was not typically something good wizards did. But, and it was a big but, crap happened. Not only were there the obvious examples of Harry Potter and Molly Weasley, but there were other things to consider. "What if someone gets in the path of a spell you cast at someone else? Should hitting an innocent person in that way label you a dark wizard?" The answer was obvious, people. "Obviously, intent has to be considered a big part of what makes a person dark or not." Duh.

06-08-2019, 01:02 PM	#33 (permalink)
lazykitty Ramora Join Date: Aug 2010 Location: Valhalla Posts: 5,651 x7 x4	Dem Carters \| even 🕊🕊 have pride \| \| Expecto PAWtronum 🐈 \| U-NA-GI Pot stirring? Yes please. In her opinion, there were TOO MANY people who were afraid of doing so in the wizarding world right now, which made for a very boring time for all. So, bring on the pot stirring. And in that spirit.... Quote: Originally Posted by Nordic Witch After a short breath Ellie added "Um, I think you're also seen as a dark wizard by the public if you illegally breed dark creatures." Other than that she didn’t know what to contribute to what everyone else was already saying. "By that logic, Rubeus Hagrid would be a dark wizard," she began with a chuckle, "thanks to his Blast-Ended Skrewts. Not to mention his half-giant status. Also, Professor O'Hara and her family, since she's part-goblin." And she didn't think anyone would call either of them dark, especially not Hagrid. I mean, the guy was loyal to Harry Potter to the very end! Now, for the whole killing debate. Yes, killing people was not typically something good wizards did. But, and it was a big but, crap happened. Not only were there the obvious examples of Harry Potter and Molly Weasley, but there were other things to consider. "What if someone gets in the path of a spell you cast at someone else? Should hitting an innocent person in that way label you a dark wizard?" The answer was obvious, people. *"Obviously, intent has* to be considered a big part of what makes a person dark or not." Duh. __________________ Days of Potter 2023:___________________________ Which Bertie Botts Flavour Are You? You are Salt**!