While losing points didn't seem so bad, getting several weeks worth of detention for refusing to clean up a mess they didn't make sounded much worse. Yup. Punish those that hadn't been involved. Smooth, real smooth. Hogwarts was turning into a joke, a bad one at that.

"Yes, Sir," Rylee replied her entire demeanor changing as she glanced at Nathan catching a quick glimpse of a certain look he sent her way. There was no sense in making a fuss and getting into worse trouble. If they were bound to get themselves detention at some point it was going to be for something they had actually done.

Nathan's question about cleaning supplies was indeed a very good one. This had the small third year looking over at the cold eyed man that was Professor Ainsworth. Could they use the cleaning supplies from the supplies closet or was he going to conjure up what he wanted them to use?