Kitty looked down at her desk at Professor Stewart's stern look. It wasn't fair at all! Last year when she'd criticized Salathar Slytherin, Katy had insulted her and said that she HATED her. Granted, Kitty had returned the insult - but that didn't change that Katy started it. So why did Katy get to attack her hero (Pinkstone) and then cry about feeling attacked when Kitty very politely tried to question her?

Not thinking about Katy, Kitty did her best to answer the next questions. "For the first scenario I would of course break the Statute to save my friends life. Even if it wasn't my friend and it was a complete stranger, I would still save her or his life. If we're allowed to use magic to save one of our own, then we should do the same for Muggles. But for the second scenario I wouldn't break the Statute, because I wouldn't want to go to Azkaban just to impress my friends."

Would Katy save a Muggle friend if it meant breaking the Statute? Did she even have Muggle friends, Kitty wondered?