Never a dull moment at Hogwarts. Shay just sat back and listened. She had given her opinion and that was that for her. However, things were starting to get a little testy. Fortunately though, it seemed that things were not going to to get out of hand. Not yet anyway. Professor Stewart gave her thoughts and then prepared some hypothetical scenarios. One was not hard for Shay to comment on. The other one, well that remained to be seen.

Shay had to think about it for a moment. When she had made her decision, she raised her hand. "With scenario number two, no I would not use my magical skills to entertain muggles. That is so unnecessary. If I was going to break the statute of Secrecy, it would not be for something as unimportant as that.". Taking a breath, Shay went on. "On the other hand, if it was a matter of life and death........I would have to think twice. If I could save my friend's life, I would probably try it.......that is if no muggle methods were working. Now of course I wouldn't be obvious. I would try a very discreet non verbal healing charm." Shay knew that this was probably not what her professors wanted to hear. But if this wasn't an exceptional circumstance, she didn't know what was. "If the accident was in fact fatal, then there would be nothing I could do to help my friend. No magic could help them."