Carlton was BEAMING. The professor had called his suggestion creative. Creative. It wasn't the spell the professor was looking for, but it was creative which was almost as good. If not better.

But before he had the time to bask in his creative ideas they were already moving along. The Banishing Charm. Well OK then. He didn't know that one. But Rooney was still teaching him Accio so he still had a lot to learn. Speaking of Accio, it seemed like the spell all the students said now. Carlton bounced a little. He almost knew that spell! He was so proud.

Maybe the encouraging comment from professor Marchand had gotten to his head because his hand was soon in the air again, even though everyone else had already said Accio, which was probably the correct one. But Carlton was creative, according to the professor, so he had to say something. "What about levitating it towards you, professor? OR, if you did transform it into a dog, you can call on it and give it dog treats." Because his dog always came when he had treats.

Was this also a creative answer, professor Marchand?! BEAM.