DMC Puffskein
Join Date: Nov 2011 Location: Hogwarts :)
Posts: 1,351
Hogwarts RPG Name: Ally Rory Slytherin First Year | Stay Free Quote:
Originally Posted by hermionesclone Text Cut: You guys ^^
Well this was an interesting development, wasn't it?
Hirsch had paused in his walking around the classroom to see what Miss Tyler was making with her lump of clay. He wasn't about to mention it but the man was slightly glad that she hadn't gone with the previous idea she had, whatever it was.
And her answer? Even more interesting. "Eye contact is crucial, yes," Probably not the answer he was going for but it was a good one. "So you're saying that the intention to cast the dark magic depends on the person and why they have the intention of casting it?" Another good point, he had to admit.
This answer to his previous question was like music to the man's ears. In fact, most of the answers had been. "I'm glad you mentioned something about creatures as well as spellwork." Because those were also Dark Arts. "But you're very right: without the intention to cast a Dark spell, you're not going to succeed, no matter how much you try. Well done."
Focus? Hm. "You're very right about that since without focus, you're not going to be able to cast your spell properly and it could go wrong. That's not the answer I'm looking for but good guess."
Oh, this answer. This was an answer that earned the biggest smile from the Defence Professor. "You are very close, Miss Evans. I like your mention of corruption with this as well." She would probably find out why soon enough. "Excellent thinking."
And onto her next part which, luckily, the man could answer seeing as he'd been at Durmstrang himself. "Depends on the countries and their laws. While we may be united by a force and as a nation, who's to say that every country has a clear and united idea of right and wrong? A spell that one country might consider to be okay might not be somewhere else." "But to answer your question: Durmstrang prefers a more combative approach to magical education. At Durmstrang, you're taught darker arts because they believe that young students should be taught these things at a young age so that they don't have a rosy-eyed vision of the world and the dark arts. This is partly due to early influences in the curriculum, especially by Harfang Munter, an ex-Durmstrang leader. Hogwarts is different because the laws here are different. You're taught to recognise the Dark Arts and to fight them, yes," And he tried his best to do just that. "but with a much softer approach. Does that help?"
Soon enough, Hirsch found himself moving over towards a certain Miss Summers, and looking over her work as well. He wouldn't have usually but the words 'dark moments/thoughts' caught his eye and he found himself frowning in thought. He silently wished she had elaborated on this answer but, as it was, there was nothing else to go off of. "Close," he said quietly, tapping her notes. That was all.
Oh, this answer. This answer made him very happy, a fact that probably showed on his face. "You have potential, you know." Make of that what you will, Botros.
As for her answer, "You, and Miss Evans, are probably the closest to the correct answer. You can't attack or defend yourself properly if you let your emotions get in the way so having control over them is crucial. It's probably why people who practice the dark arts to cause harm are often seen as being heartless. Excellent thinking."
The sailor snowman was what caught Hirsch's attention and he took a moment to look at the lump of clay with an amused expression on his face. Oh, how he wanted to see what the young Gryffindor would make of the rest of the lesson.
Willpower? Interesting word choice. "That comes very close to intent, Tenacius, but you're still right. If you don't truly want to cast the spell, you won't be able to. Simple as that."
Jace was being very precise with his moulding, something Hirsch noticed when he walked past the young Ravenclaw. It was almost as if the boy was in his element. Huh.
Determination was another interesting answer. "Well, yes, I guess. You need determination, or a certain level of confidence, to carry out the spell. Without it, your attempts will be futile." A spell casting fact. "It's...... not quite the answer I'm looking for but it's a good guess, Jace. Well done."
Why was Rooney Bronwyn acting so weird? Because this, surely, wasn't what he was usually like.
Hirsch was very much confused.
So, for the time being, he was going to concentrate on something he did understand: the Ravenclaw's answer. "It's always the innocent ones that prove to be the most surprising." Just something to remember. "Understanding is a good answer. If you don't truly understand what it is you're doing or trying to cast, you're not going to be very successful in your spell-casting," Probably why they taught the meaning behind the spells. "Not exactly the answer I'm looking for but it's a very good and unique guess."
Another understanding answer? Well that was something. "Understanding is key, yes. Without it, you won't know exactly what it is you're trying to do. And it's probably why we teach you about the dark arts so that you can understand them and know how to effectively defend yourselves against them." Still key. "Not the answer I'm looking for but a very good guess."
A quiet person? Not bad, not bad. Especially considering the fact that she was taking notes, from the looks of it. Hirsch didn't have anything to say and didn't look at her notes as he swept past.
And what was she going to make out of that clay, hm?
Unfortunately for the boy, Hirsch had swept past him just after he'd finished muttering so he couldn't catch whatever it was he was muttering to himself. And, frankly, he wasn't going to pretend as though he had heard. Not when he had other things to concentrate on.
Like the boy's answer, for example.
Desire? "You're very right in your thinking, Mr Winchester. Without the desire, you can wave your wand all you like but you won't be able to cast the spell properly." Funny mental image there. "That ties in with intent, actually. Not the answer I'm looking for but good guess."
Focus? Well, it was a good thing that his students knew that they needed to concentrate if they wanted to cast a spell properly. "Focus is correct, yes, and it's an important part of spell casting but not the fourth factor we're looking for."
As for her question, specifically about the Dueling Club, Hirsch stopped in his tracks and turned to peer at her. "Miss Valentine, you're not a dark witch and I have faith that you won't end up being one." Surely, she wouldn't upset him so by taking that career path. "But no. No one in Dueling Club is intending to cause severe harm, so much that they kill their opponent. Remember that these spells you use are only considered dark or not depending on how you use them. If you want to tickle someone just to get them to laugh or to out-duel them, that's fine. If you tickle someone to death, that's not."
Pause. "And I oversee every single duel. I wouldn't let people use these spells in a dark way." Did that reassure her?
Daxton being quiet in his lesson was hardly a surprise to the man but it didn't stop him from walking past his desk, mostly to check that he was still paying attention. It was the sight of the fingers rhythmically drumming the table that caught his attention and gave him some kind of indication that he was, probably, listening. Even if the gesture looked as though he was a little bored of the discussion.
The man raised his eyebrows at the young Ravenclaw but said nothing else. This won't be a boring lesson, Daxton, don't worry.
There were a lot of focus answers popping up, weren't there? Again, the man was glad that they knew how much concentration they needed in their spell casting but they probably didn't realise just how close they were to the actual answer. It did tie in well with the fourth factor but for now........ "You're right about needing to focus to cast your spells, Miss Darcy, but that's not the fourth factor. But I do like your mention of sharp instincts as well." Constant vigilance, remember?
Another quiet one? No matter. This didn't bother the man in the slightest and, in fact, he actually expected it. Though, this was a little surprising considering how great of an answer her - he was going to take a stab in the dark - sister had managed to produce and how good this Botros was at this subject.
Oh, this was a new answer, wasn't it? The man stopped to look at the young girl, a little impressed with this. "Well, you're certainly right about that, Miss Toussaint," he started, "They say that practice makes perfect and you need a certain level of skill to cast the right spells. Well done." Again, not exactly the answer but a logical answer nonetheless.
Practice? Hm. "You're certainly right about needing practice to cast the spell. Practice does make perfect." And some needed more than others, which was fine. "It's not the fourth element, however, but well done."
Willingness. He hadn't had that word come up before. "Willingness is a good way of putting it, in fact," he said, nodding his head slowly, "If you're not willing to cast the spell, you won't be able to. Simple as that. But that ties in very closely with intent so no, it's not the fourth factor. Good guess, though."
Hirsch had been blissfully ignoring whatever it was that was going on between Miss Tate and Miss Toussaint. That was, until, something flew out from Miss Tate's direction and straight towards........
............ SMACK!
....................... What was that about constant vigilance?
Hirsch, who'd jumped when the small lump of clay slapped his arm, found himself readjusting his askew glasses and frowning down at the clay on the floor and then towards the Gryffindor. "Miss Tate, when I said that you can make whatever you wish with your clay, I didn't mean for a clayball to be one of them." Again, teenagers. "But you're right: you need a level of capability with these spells. Most of them are going to be advanced. The intention you need to muster up is advanced."
............
Well well well. "That's a very interesting answer, Miss Traulton. They say that the Dark Arts consume you if you become too connected to it and that ties in with what you mentioned about being emotionally invested into that area of magic. That could be a branch off of intent but you are right about needing to be connected with it to perform it." At least, that was his understanding of it.
And no, that wasn't the fourth factor.
Another quiet student? Hirsch didn't mind this, not at all. Instead, when he reached her table, he paused to take a look at whatever it was she was making before moving onwards. It would be interesting to see what they made of these clay figures later.
What was surprising was that Zeke Browne hadn't offered an answer. The Defence Professor half expected the boy to come out with something unique and different but not this time. Maybe he had a different tactic, instead.
Whatever it was, the boy was bound to excel so he wasn't too worried.
Emotion was a very interesting answer and, in fact, it was one that got the man smiling. And what was more was that she had mentioned a little something that he was looking for. "That's a very unique answer, Miss Phillips," he said, pushing his glasses further up his nose, "People do say that you need to be tough and emotion-less when dealing with this form of magic but if you have your emotions in check, you could still be an exceptional witch or wizard. Well done."
This was concerning. Very concerning.
Hirsch had arrived close enough to Miss Franks-Mundie in time to see the slightly distressed pulling of the clay and the small pieces that sat on her desk. Hm. He didn't know what the problem was but what he did know was that this wasn't the sign of a happy student.
Unless ripping clay made the girl happy.
He tilted his head at her and gave her a thumbs up coupled with a questioning look on his face, as if he was trying to ask a question with a simple look.
Hirsch had no idea what it was that Haddie was trying to make with her lump of clay and he wasn't about to question it. Though, he had to hand it to her, she did seem to like getting the detailing right.
Want to hurt someone? "Yes, very much so. Some people use emotion to do that, others visualisation. But, this need, this intent to hurt someone needs to be there otherwise it can't work. You're very right." Except, not what he was looking for.
As a whole, Hirsch was incredibly impressed with the answers the class had come out with. No one had mentioned exactly what he was thinking, but there were some creative answers here. Some that he hadn't even thought of, actually. And a few of them had managed to get very close to the answer he was looking for. Closer than, probably, even they knew. "Really excellent suggestions, everyone, but Miss Evans, Miss Botros and Miss Phillips have nearly hit the nail with their answers." A pause to smile in their directions before he moved on. "The fourth factor that's important is control. You can have the wand movement and incantation nailed down and have all the intention to cast the spell in the world but without control, you're likely to fail."
Should he elaborate? He was going to. "The reason why some Dark wizards fail is because of their lack of control. Without it, the dark magic could very easily backfire on you, causing you harm in turn. It could cause some permanent damage, which is why some say that these wizards tend to look corrupted. They can be too focused on the intent, the desire to cause harm, that some don't bother learning to control it. It could change their entire look, making them look more and more twisted. This could also be because they let their malicious intent get the better of them." All consuming, wasn't it? "An example of a lack of control turning out bad for the user is in the case of Fiendfyre. Many of you would know the events of the Second Wizarding War and the incident in which one individual lost control of the cursed fire and ended up dying in it. It's the same with even the minor of spells: lose control and you might end up causing more harm than you mean to." Something to think about, wasn't it? "So!" he said, coming to the front of the class again, "Spellwork and wand magic in general isn't the only branch of magic that is associated with the Dark Arts. Can anyone think of any other kind of magic, whether it's a subject taught here at Hogwarts or not, that could influence and be associated with the Dark Arts?" OOC: You guys are doing SO well so far! <3 Sorry if this question is confusing! Just have your charrie name any other branch of magic that could be linked to the Dark Arts. Aaaaaanything ^^
Tegan will continue the next part of the class <3
So let's see. Everyone was already answering the questions so there was nothing else he could think of really. So, Jonas just kept silent. He frowned though as Professor didn't elaborate on the second wizard war. Jonas made a mental note to look it up later in the library.
|