SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post

StarShine · 06-13-2015, 06:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tiro MacMhuirich

Marsha nodded slightly, pondering this new information as she was given it. It seemed like tampering with anything was a bad move. With emotions… with memories… with feelings… Hmm. ”Why do so many people attempt to tamper with … well anything and different part of people if it isn’t good or nice to do so?” The Welsh girl was confused. So, confused.

Though, the Professor confirmed what she thought about the - OH, they were called the Unforgiveables. Okay. Yeah, he confirmed that they were bad. REALLLLY bad, so she would definitely be staying away from them… and she nodded, accepting that in comparison to other things that could be cast, how innocent the forgetfulness potion was. So, did that make it okay? That it became innocent when comparing it to something bad, because by that… she could punch one of her cousins and say ‘what? I didn’t kill them!’. …

”So… Do things fall on a scale? Like, something is okay as long as it isn’t unforgivable bad… or is it normally situation dependant?” Big questions before dinner. WHEEEEE..

Cosgrach shrugged. "That's why we have 'good' and 'evil'." It was dark people's work... mostly. But sometimes, people did it to... 'experiment' too. Cosgrach didn't even know.

"Well..." Tough question. "It usually depends on situations. There are some situations where even the simplest spells do harm. But there's a general consensus. If it alters something negatively forever - however, obliviators are different because they protect our society - if it alters negatively forever, then it's usually bad. If it takes the willpower of someone, no matter for how long, it's forbidden." Was he... forgetting something? Nah... He hoped he didn't confuse her further.

06-13-2015, 06:14 AM	#19 (permalink)
StarShine DoM Kappa Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Cell culture hood Posts: 13,005 Hogwarts RPG Name: Mona Deandra Hellmann Gryffindor First Year x5 x6	¼ of the Sisterhood of the Traveling Pls Quote: Originally Posted by Tiro MacMhuirich Marsha nodded slightly, pondering this new information as she was given it. It seemed like tampering with anything was a bad move. With emotions… with memories… with feelings… Hmm. ”Why do so many people attempt to tamper with … well anything and different part of people if it isn’t good or nice to do so?” The Welsh girl was confused. So, confused. Though, the Professor confirmed what she thought about the - OH, they were called the Unforgiveables. Okay. Yeah, he confirmed that they were bad. REALLLLY bad, so she would definitely be staying away from them… and she nodded, accepting that in comparison to other things that could be cast, how innocent the forgetfulness potion was. So, did that make it okay? That it became innocent when comparing it to something bad, because by that… she could punch one of her cousins and say ‘what? I didn’t kill them!’. … ”So… Do things fall on a scale? Like, something is okay as long as it isn’t unforgivable bad… or is it normally situation dependant?” Big questions before dinner. WHEEEEE.. Cosgrach shrugged. "That's why we have 'good' and 'evil'." It was dark people's work... mostly. But sometimes, people did it to... 'experiment' too. Cosgrach didn't even know. "Well..." Tough question. "It usually depends on situations. There are some situations where even the simplest spells do harm. But there's a general consensus. If it alters something negatively forever - however, obliviators are different because they protect our society - if it alters negatively forever, then it's usually bad. If it takes the willpower of someone, no matter for how long, it's forbidden." Was he... forgetting something? Nah... He hoped he didn't confuse her further.