Flobberworms:
- Hairy & Lucy
- Matilda
Augureys:
- Eddy
- Susie
Fairies:
- Tails & Tinker, Fairy & Bell | Owner(s): Angel & Aubrey Valentine (Harry174 & PhoenixStar)
- One girl fairy (rainbow wings with a purple dot) | Owner(s): Ezekiel Rogers (Hera)
- Two fairies |Owner(s): Benjamin Atreyu (Holmesian Feline)
- Two fairies (charmed electric punk haired) | Owner(s): Puck Greyvson (Optimist)
- Zelda & Lily | Owner(s): Sophie Brown (feeheeheeny)
- One fairy with dimples | Owner(s): Gabriel Banner (Govoni) & Zahra Kettleburn (Mad Eye Touz)
- Fred, Duffy & Snooki | Owner(s): Eden McGee (kayquilz) & Layla Ackerly (Lottiepot)
- Violet (purple wings) & Trinny (pink wings); (Gold-tinted hair) | Owner(s): Beverly Wayne (Deezers)
- Skye (shorter hair, taller) & Lisa | Owner(s): Grayson Whitlock (hermionesclone)
- Justin (longer blue wings) & Tinkerbelle (pink wings) | Owner(s): Kace Lecium (Expecto-Penguin)
- ( One transparent wings) & ( One taller, multi-coloured wings) | Owner(s): Aditya Rehman (FearlessLeader19)
- Cordelia (tallest girl), Puck, Tink (largest wings) & Spyro (purple and smallest) | Owner(s): Tobias Fuller-Thompson (Felixir)
- Two fairies | Owner(s): Lux Carrington (Squishy)
- Trout (silver wings), Eggplant (purple wings) | Donated by: Alexa Cambridge (DaniDiNardo)
- Berry (blue wings), Salmon (pink wings) | Owner(s): Dima Toussaint (lemon)
Puffskeins:
- Archie & Daisy
- Bubbily
- Pepsi
- Dawn
Nifflers:
- Dash
- Itchy & Bibsy
- Hades
- Ducky
- George
- Goldilocks
- Pipsqueak
Hippogriffs:*
- Buddy & Charlene
- Henry
- Ruffles & Springy
- Helios
- Hippie & Skippy
- Waterwings
- Monty & Molly
- Grey Feathers
Winged Horses:*
- Corena & Oslo
- January & June
- Bear & Rose
- Apollo
- Cygnus & Eridanus
- Ise
- Glitterfly
- Fury & Estelle
- Lincoln
Others:*
- One Crup; Azalea | Owner(s): Zander Adair (ArianaBlack)
* denotes requiring permission from Professor Thompson by signing up to be a Creatures Playmate in order to interact with them.