SPOILER!!: Adi would know you no matter your illusion, Benny :P
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Holmesian Feline 
Benny was right...he was starring into the face and appearance of the famous magizoologist and writer of the most well-known book on magical creatures. "Well creatures are ---" he started to say, explaining his ability to pick up on Newt Scamander once he realized it but caught himself halfway through his original statement. Nope...nope...nope. That would reveal him right away. Or almost right away depending on who was on the other end of the guess.
Quick, turn the attention around, he instructed himself, turning his attention to what his companion was saying. Cheeriest and friendliest house ghost? Well Sir Nicholas was real friendly, especially to Gryffindors. And the only ghost that didn't have moments of cheer was the Bloody Baron. "A Hufflepuff?"
As for the question asked him, Benny nodded solemnly before sighing softly at the thought. "Uh huh...I used to be." Stupid ruling that meant they weren't allowed to play it anymore. He wondered what had made Newt ask that which made him think on who could be behind Newt. "Are you a fifth year?"
What was that? This person behind the illusion was about to say something about creatures? What exactly, though? Creatures were awesome? The best things in this world? Fun? Not so fun? Terrifying? Hmmm...
"Yes, I'm a Hufflepuff.'' The best House of the four did have the friendliest and cheeriest ghostie. This person was one step closer to figuring out who he was. Not that it would be that difficult since he was such a Social Badger.
Aha. So his partner played on the Quidditch team.
"Let's see...Quidditch player so that puts him or her roughly around my age.'' Since the game hadn't been around for a few years, he could safely eliminate those a few years below him.
"Quidditch team, chose Charlie Weasley who loved creatures especially dragons... Well, I'll be darned!'' Adi had figured it out!
"You're Benjamin Atreyu.'' Adi would have more than loved to say 'YOU'RE BENNNNNY!' but that would have given his own identity away way too easily. Hehe. But see? He still figured out his bestie was behind Charlie's illusion.
No wonder they ended up partnering with each other without meaning to. They had both found the identities of Newt and Charlie VERY interesting since he and Benny had a thing for creatures also.