"Thanks," he said with a nod, accepting the cup of tea. He added some lemon and honey before taking a sip. Well, it didn't TASTE poisoned...

Being a Quidditch captain helped and Lafay totally agreed. Smirk. Although... he wasn't sure WHY he was smirking. This was all rather odd, especially since she wasn't yelling at him or anything. Milton took another sip of his tea as she questioned his charming personality. "Well, I suppose my attractiveness is an objective thing." And honestly, he was okay with Lafay not thinking he was attractive. But how did he define charming? "Attractive personality. Which I have. Most of the time." It was hard to be charming when your Potions teacher was getting on your last nerve, though. Milton shrugged again. "It depends on the person and situation. I'm not always charming." But she probably knew that.