Minerva bit her lip thinking about this. If she could would she. This was such a hard one, especially with her life right now.She thought about her family and what it would be like if she could use these exceptions. It would be better, wouldn't it. She would have a happy loving family, not two cousins taking care of her that she really didn't want to be near, but even if she could use these would she. She thought about her time at church with her family and everything that was said. A good Min/bad Min started in her head. So many things she questioned about her self with this thought of a possibility.

Minerva put up her hand. "Professor, this is a very hard question. As much as I would like to say no I would not do it, it's wrong and people might think bad of me. I'm not sure I wouldn't use them. Especially the life at this moment, but if I were to go against everything I have ever learned as a child and be considered maybe even dark because of it, if the life could be produced exactly the way it left it's hard for me to say that I wouldn't. If the life exception could be used, but you still wouldn't have them exactly as before they left you then I'm going to say that I probably wouldn't use it."

She looked down at her desk wondering what her classmates thought of her. Even thinking about bringing family back from the dead made her feel like a bad person, but she just didn't know if she would go through with it or not given the opportunity to hug family members, feel their hugs, and hear their voices again.