Quote:
Originally Posted by
Tegz 
West looked at the Hufflepuff and sorta added on to that, hand vaguely up, cos she was kinda missing something important in his firstie expert opinion. "But you can bring people back to a semblance of life. At least, you can reanimate them. Necromancy and stuff. Its just not real life. And its dark magic."
Quote:
Originally Posted by
FireboltAvis88 Alyssa nodded when she heard the first year's answer. "Yes I agree that some people may bring back the dead to some semblance of life, like the Inferi for example, but if one had the ability to bring someone back to life, why don't they just bring them all the way back to life and be a regular human being again, instead of giving them an aimless kind of life?" Alyssa paused as she wondered that herself.
Minerva had sat listening to all the answers, when she heard Alyssa and this first year respond. She placed her hand up.
"I agree with both of you, but like I said earlier, bringing back someone from the dead is not bringing them back really. Like you both said you can bring a body back, but it's not going to be the exact person you knew when alive. There soul has went to it's new adventure so your just reviving an empty body." Well that's what her muggle Sunday School classes would teach her about souls and death.