View Single Post
Old 07-15-2011, 06:54 PM   #111 (permalink)
severus94
Slytherin
Dugbog
 
severus94's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 107
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by skinny_bones4 View Post
Since there is so much for me to say, I posted the rest on a seperate page. The link is located at the bottom. But without further wait, my review:

While the overall plot was the same, I would say that only 40% of the film was truthful to the book. While I probably will always be known as the book critic that looks for any little detail that has changed, this film changed so many things that I finally looked at my friend and said "This isn't right." Some things include the change where the death of Snape occured, the severe damage that was dealt on Hogwarts, the sneak attack that occured inside the castle, with the film version having Harry disguise as a student to get into the Great Hall, with the Order of the Pheonix shortly behind him. We also see the final scene change greatly. Instead of it starting at the castle entrance, then finishing in the Great Hall, the film starts it at the entrance, then takes it to the top of the castle, then to the clocktower, then back to the entrance where it ends.

Another thing that changed drastically was the end that occured after Voldemort's death. We don't see the celebration occur in the Great Hall, nor do we see the professors return the school colors back on the walls. We then don't see Harry and the gang head up to Dumbledore's office and have one last conversation with his portrait and determine what to do with the Deathly Hallows. We don't see Harry restore his wand with the Elder Wand and then agree to return it to Dumbledore's tomb, nor do we see them discuss about the stone and cloak. Instead, we see Harry break the wand in two and throw it down into the depths. And you would think that they would have talked about the Hallows more since the past two movies were titled "Deathly Hallows."

You can finish the rest of my review here: Tyler's World: It All Ends
absolotely agree with u , at the end i felt that there is something wrong where is the celebration , after all voldemort is finished , people should see what's happening after that and the epilouge... it was short really , i liked it but in the book it was longer , warmer and definitely funneir i really wouldn't want the final 5 second of 10 years trip end with that look of the trio towards the train i would have reccomended a quick warm funny word from ron
severus94 is offline   Reply With Quote