Marie watched as Evan rubbed his head. Oh great, now he was probably going to accuse her of giving him a headache. But he didn't, instead he acts like she was insulting him. Well... truth hurts doesn't it. "Fine, no insults." She sat there and listened as he finally told his side of the story. When he was finished talking all Marie could do was shake her head a little. "What am I going to do with you boys?" She asked with less anger now. "You know that Carter is Mina's best friend, just like you're mine. And we ALL know that you and Carter pretty much hate each other. Was it really necessary to bring up your relationship with Mina to him? You're a smart guy Evan, I'm pretty sure you knew something like that, no matter what your meaning, would anger him." Just like she knew how much it angered Caroline when she taunted her about Carter.

Oh Merlin. Evan and his stinking football. She wasn't even going to comment on that one because she still didn't like that sport herself and she was sure that whatever she said would only anger Evan again and then they would be yelling at each other again.

Okay, now that made her mad her off... again, but she tried her best not to show it. "Really, you think Carter deceived me just to get with me Evan? You really don't believe in me at all do you? Do you really find it so hard to believe that I really did like Carter and that he really did treat me good? He was a good boyfriend to me Evan and even though our relationship ended the way it did, I won't take away how good he treated me before all that love potion crap. Just like I won't take away how good you and I were together... before you disappeared." It was true, both boys had treated her wrong in the end but they had also both been good to her too. That she would never take away from either of them. Hearing him say carter told him about Mina living him she just rolled her eyes. "Did you ever stop to think that maybe he said that to get to you for what you were saying about him?" It was true, Mina had at one time been in love with Carter. Marie knew that very well herself. It was because of Mina's love for Carter that the two girls didn't get along at all in he beginning.

So, he didn't actually say she cheated on him but he did say Carter tried getting her to cheat on him. Well now, if that isn't the pot calling the kettle black. Who was it just last term was pretty much cheating on Mina? Who was it that was flirting around every chance he got with a certain Gryffindork prefect? And no, she wasn't talking about Patroclus here. "Believe it or not Evan, Carter did not ever try to get me to cheat on you. He was nothing more than a friend that was trying to help me find you. He knew how much I was hurting by not knowing where you were. He never did anything to betray the friendship we had." Sure, Carter may have been falling for Marie at the time, but he never let on to her about it.

"Trust me Evan, I know you're over me and I made sure Carter knows it too. I let him know that you are in love with Mina and that we are only friends, nothing more." Okay, now that one she wasn't expecting. "His effect on me?" Oh, that. "You know, the way I reacted is no different than the way you two were reacting with each other. I may not have spelled it out at first but I did ask you to explain yourself..."

What the hell!? Did he really hear her say those words? "THAT is NOT what I said Evan. I said after four years you bring this crap up again." That was NOT her saying he hadn't moved on. "You know, this whole fight was nothing more than a HUGE misunderstanding from everyone involved, and I still don't know why you would bring something up that happened so long ago. I really thought we had gotten past all that Evan." She hated this. Evan was her best friend and Carter and her were just starting to be friends again. Why couldn't they just all get along? Everyone had moved on and was happy with someone else now.