Benjamin happened to be sitting on the couch in front of the fireplace when Professor Lafay came in and stood in the way of the door when she let her voice open up and practically yelled in the common room to be heard across the whole dungeon area. He quickly covered his ears and muttered "Bloody hell that's loud." then he remembered something. "Professor! I need to have a conference with you in your office after we're all done here, please?!?!" He thought she heard him because she turned her head toards him toyell down the into the dorms.