SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post

Tazenhani · 05-17-2015, 05:43 AM

SPOILER!!: Responses to Greetings - replies within

Quote:

Originally Posted by nicole black

He had a moment of wanting to say something else, though he didn’t know what- but then the Professor spoke, his silvery Otter of a patronus was crawling over Damien’s shoulders and sitting on top of his head as if this was it’s natural nest. The Gryffindor chuckled with surprise, and did his best to reach up and try to itch the technically non-existing creature.

The patronus had the desired effect, and Sabel was relieved to see that the boy's mood could turn about. Hopefully, it would be a small help in encouraging him into a better mood. He'd need it for the remainder of the class.

Quote:

Originally Posted by WeasleyGirl

Hugo tilted his head to one side in confusion. He slightly opened his mouth to answer the professor. What's down? what was that? Adults and their answers. "I'll think about it..."

He probably shouldn't have been having so much fun, but he really couldn't help it. "Let me know what you come up with. I'm curious too." Why ask a question, if you weren't expecting an answer, after all.

Quote:

Originally Posted by FearlessLeader19

And then it was on his head, where he couldn't see much but when it hit the floor, he said, "Patronuses are such fun.'' Well, Professor Sabel's was anyway. Speaking of which... "I'll hold you to that, Professor.'' With a happy grin, he sidled off.

The boy got a knowing grin. "See that you do. I like to keep my promises."

Quote:

Originally Posted by kayquilz

Looking up as Professor Dakest started speaking, she smiled and nodded. "Oh-yes, sir--just in a good mood today--" Merlin. Even professors had started noticing her good moods? She must have been really mopey before...hmph. But the weekend had been so GREAT.

Sabel nodded with a return smile. "Good. I hope that this class doesn't disturb your mood." Because it would either go really well, or really poorly with bitter disappointment. He was, of course, hoping for the former.

Quote:

Originally Posted by feeheeheeny

Sophie DID want to conjure her own patronus and let their otter and ferret scamper about the room together, but she had read the rules and knew better than to practice without permission. She could SEE the calculating in his eyes, too, and noted that he did not tell her she could do her own, so... she nodded back in silent understanding. She didn't FULLY catch onto his line of thinking yet, but she would. No big deal. She didn't need to show it off anyway.

He did regret it, just a little bit, that he hadn't asked for a student demonstration. Perhaps at some point in time, he would. If it was applicable, if it would prove helpful. For now, he was simple grateful that Brown seemed to understand not only his initial consideration, but his reluctance to follow through with it as well.

Quote:

Originally Posted by fanficfanatict

Hugh was NOT fine. He wasn't embarassed, as Hughbert's didn't get embarassed but he might have been flushed. In a taken off guard kind of way.

But not embarrassed.

He did not acknowledge Dakest's inquiry, yo. He sort of fumbled through a response of nonsensical words and then shut up. Nailed it.

He was.....okay? Something of the sort. Sabel couldn't really catch what the boy had said, but he didn't seem to be limping or crying or anything of the sort so it was probably best to just let it go. At least the stares weren't still happening.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mell

"You're easily impressed Kettleburn." He could show her his Patronus if she wanted. It was better than the Professor's except that he hadn't quite managed to hold onto his Patronus for very long.
And he was just about to tell her that too when he realised that the Professor was talking to them. Apparently the man didn't think that their gum trick was very cool. Not wanting to get a detention so early into the term, he immediately swallowed his piece of gum.

Well, that was one way to make quick work of the gum. Didn't really help with the concern of a choking hazard, but the kid seemed to be maintaing breathing function, so he let it go. Warning had been recieved and abided by, he couldn't ask for more than that. "Thank you, Mr. Toussaint.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Expecto-Penguin

As Kace greeted Professor Dakest, he smirked and knew he was going to bring up his career choices. He began to say, "I actually knew what I wanted to do. I mean I made an appointment with the Care of Magical Creatures teacher to discuss options. I realized I do love animals though." he shrugged and hoped it didn't sound too cheesy.

A pleased, and admittedly somewhat relieved, smile took over. "Good for you. I hope your discussion helps you start off in the right direction." Sorry Rainey, one less for the ranks.

SPOILER!!: Answers about Curiosity and Testing the Forbidden

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kaos.Doodles

Without much hesitation Kyroh raised his hand. "People are often in interested in what they don't know or aren't allowed to know." He paused to yawn. " The more you make something off limits the more interested we get. It's like with the Dark Arts and Dark Magic. We're told it's bad and not to do it, and that's the problem." And his dad had never told him that before. Nope......Possibly.

Quote:

Originally Posted by WeasleyGirl

Hugo tilted his head to one side in confusion. He slightly opened his mouth to answer the professor. What's down? what was that? Adults and their answers. "I'll think about it..."
Class began and Hugo raised his hand to answer the first question. "Because of curiosity. Everyone tell us that dark magic and everything related to it is bad, so... he shrugged "I don't know. I like to know about stuff that are like 'forbidden', they are way more interesting to read about " and no, he wasn't planning on becoming a dark wizard.

Quote:

Originally Posted by fire_faerie

"I think I agree with the curiosity for the unknown. It's dark, it's dangerous, we don't know much about it but we DO know that it is capable of far worse things than just killing," Benzi raised his hands, thinking while talking. "There's just something stupidly exhilarating about that... And, right, so learning about the dark arts and dark wizards themselves is fascinating in and of itself, but then learning that we can actually beat them? They're so good with magic, the dark arts are incredibly strong and potent, and then learning that we can counter that with good magic? I think that's the best part."

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harry174

Angel raised her hand. "Professor it's because you are told that they are dangerous and many people like children when they are told not to do something they have to try it so that they can see why they are told not too." Angel had a few stories she could tell the Professor but she would probably get into trouble for them.

Quote:

Originally Posted by GoldenSnake

"Humans are naturally curious." Natalia gave a simple explanation, shrugging slightly afterwards to show her uncertainty of her own comment. It was understandable to her why wizards would like to discover more about dark magic: it was mysterious. Humans throughout history have tampered with the unknowns, the enigmas, the riddles, the secrets. For what reason? - that was among the most-asked questions. Natalia, being naturally curious herself, often asked herself these philosophical questions during her free time ~~(when she was not paying attention in class)~~.
"Or more accurately, it's a mixture of curiosity and self-benefit." The Lioness added to her response.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ScarletCharm104

"Young people like to rebel, I guess. Do stuff that they're told not to do. REVERSE PSYCHOLOGY, that's it."

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daydreamer11

Finally she raised her hand and responded. "I agree with my classmates. The thing that you are forbidden to try is always the most tempting. It always seems way more glamorous than it really is when grown ups tell you not to bother with it. For me though, I always wonder what would make a person go to the dark side. Why would they do it?" Janelle wanted to know about the dark arts as a way to protect herself against it. Knowledge was power, at least that was what she believed.

Merlin, so this was the group he had to watch out for. The ones that thought just because an adult said it was a bad idea, that it was actually a good idea. Problem was, it would take their own step into adulthood to wake them up from their preconcieved notions of adults being sticklers. He knew. He'd been a kid once too.

Which was why, perhaps, he appreciated this line of answering more than most. It made sense. It was almost, expected, and in that way it was an innocent curiosity. Still... "Have you ever heard the saying, curiosity kills the cat?"

Maybe that was a bad saying to start out with. Maybe people would take offence to the killing of cats. Or killing in general. He moved on quickly. "As a word of advice, in my experience, if someone has warned against dark magic, arts or wizards, there is a very good reason they have done so. Curiosity in and off itself is not a bad thing, but you have to be mindful of what consequences may come out of it. And where you get your answers to your curiosity from."

SPOILER!!: Answers of What Drives Dark Wizards / Psychology Behind the Dark Arts

Quote:

Originally Posted by FearlessLeader19

Dark stuff? HECK YEAH! Adi found them REALLLLLY fascinating (maybe it was due to his taste in music) even though it sort of countered his bubbly personality. So what? He had been told more than once that he had a bit of Slytherin in him. The Hufflepuff raised his hand. "They are just fascinating. I know I am interested in that because I want to know what pushes people to become dark wizards and want to entangle themselves with dark magic. I think if we can get those answers, we could have less evil running around.''

Quote:

Originally Posted by kayquilz

"I think what I find most interesting is that...the bad guys...the dark wizards? They could be any of us...any one of us...if put through certain conditions and events and...upbringings...the monsters of humanity are never the ones we think...they always come from within. And this...is why it's so fascinating. Because deep down...we all have the capability."
Ahem.
What?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jessiqua

She wasn't sure if it was a call out your answer or raise your hand class, so she went formally and raised her hand anyway, waiting for an okay to speak. "Er, well I guess for me anyway, I'm intrigued about the darker side of magic because it's something I know I will never experience. Well I hope so anyway. I'd never see myself casting the unforgivable curses or duelling with anyone outside a classroom, so I suppose my mind wants the knowledge. For example, I'd never cast the cruciatus curse on anyone, and I hope it's never cast on me, but I'm interested in what reasons the caster has to cast it, and what it feels like on the victim. I suppose because I hope I never experience it I want to know about it." Did that make sense? She had a feeling she was rambling a bit and stopped, looking a bit self-conscious.

Quote:

Originally Posted by RandomRaven

"I think because... They're just curious or maybe also had a background like... They're coming from dark wizard family and stuffs. Maybe." Jackson spoke up as he raised his hand.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Expecto-Penguin

As Kace greeted [B]"Well Professor I think the dark arts are interesting because it is a topic some people would not necessarily study on their own. I mean some people would not necessarily study killing curses for fun. As for the history aspect though I find it interesting to know what other wizards have done. It makes me feel that they started out just like us. It is something we can relate to but I do like the concept of Harry Potters' history with Voldemort.." he said just thinking out loud. I mean it was on topic though.

This group of students was a little more concerning, but it was a fresh take and an answer he hadn't really been expecting. Who had thought that young students would be so interested in the minds behind the Dark Arts and Dark Magic, that psychology was a question.

A bit disconcerting. "I can't really give any testiment to sate your curiosity about the minds of Dark Wizards, except to say that it is best if you don't know them." That whole telling a student population not to do things? Right...maybe a bit more. "They are often complex and twisted, and can be so demented as to have you questioning your own morals and choices. There is a fine line between understanding, and pity. One will keep you safe, the other may put you in a very tricky spot."

He wouldn't say that most Dark Wizards had sad stories or interesting pasts, because he was sure most of the students that had offered such an answer were likely to sympathize with them. And that was a recipe for disaster.

SPOILER!!: Answers for Knowledge is Defence

This, was the answer he still struggled with himself. The benefit of dark magic, of being curious about it and learning about it. And it was also the purpose of their class. Ironic.

But at least he didn't have to worry too much about this group. Thinkers and rational with their interests. It would keep them evaluative and relatively safe. Hopefully some of the other students would pick up on similar mindsets.

He nodded, his patronus walking around him slowly before stopping at his right side. "Very right you are. Hard to defend against something you know little about." But with that knowledge, came the temptation to use and practice. "Hopefully, these DADA classes will answer some of your questions and make you prepared for what you may encounter out there."

SPOILER!!: Answers for Control and Power

These two students got a curious look. Did he have reason to be worried? It sounded like it. He shook his head, watching his patronus stretch out beside him. "Be careful not to confuse power, with a lack of responsibility and accountability. Those that are truly powerful, are those that can defend against the terrible, with restraint and gentleness."

"I suppose then, we need to find a way to learn how regular magic can be just as, or more intriguing, than the Dark Magic." His attention slid to Mancini. "And, in many cases, more powerful. Hopefully, I can show you a bit of that today."

SPOILER!!: Answers Against Interest and Intrigue

Oh. So there were students who weren't gungho about Dark Magic this and Dark Magic that? Merlin either they were pulling his leg on account of asking such a question, or they were serious. He hoped for the later, and judging by some of the expressions, he was almost positive that was the case.

He gave them both an understanding smile. "No misunderstanding Mr. Fuller-Thompson." He would make sure he got it right from now on, especially on account of the boy's reaction. "I've met a good handful of young adults who are very interested in such things." As were his classmates, but he had asked and he wouldn't berate them for answering.

Kittredge got his soft smile next. "Your answer is just as valuable as everyone else's. The Dark Arts are called such because they can be very mean and scary. A good reason to show restraint and judgement in curiosity and learning."

SPOILER!!: The Silent Lot

Quote:

Originally Posted by laurange

Brian just blinked at the professor. He was asking why the Dark Arts were fascinating? Of course they were fascinating. They were fascinating because they were taboo, and telling a bunch of teenagers that something was taboo would just make them want to do it more, right? Teenage rebellion and all that. A lot of people were saying that, though, so Brian would just keep silent for now. He was satisfied to twirl his pen around, doing funny stunts with it to keep him awake. Early morning class, y'know? He had to keep the fingers awake because then the whole body woke up.
But really. Forbidden fruit always tastes the sweetest.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Symphora

Henric didn't know how to answer Professor Dakest. Why they were so intrigued with DADA?...He had no idea why but something about defending one self in times of danger was an important part of being a wizard, wasn't it? He learnt Judo at a young age so he knew that muggles not only used it for self-defence, it was also used to show off their skills in a duel...wasn't it the same thing too for wizards? Anyone could be a dark wizard if she/he had the skills to, and in order to prevent that from happening, we need good wizards to restore the balance.

Quote:

Originally Posted by SpiritWolfe Malfoy

Only did Hady's attention shift when she heard the Professor began to speak. Very quickly hands were being raised around her...the same answers being said over and over. So really there wasn't much point in answering was there? Hady didn't think so which was why she kept quiet for now.

Quote:

Originally Posted by fanficfanatict

....he didn't answer the question though. Hugh was still struggling with the English language and it was probably for the best. He didn't have a point of view on an opinion question.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArianaBlack

When he heard Sophie's answer, he lifted his head and wore a big smile on his face. He liked her's the best. She was after all a GENIUS. Unfamiliarity made people curious. It was a simple answer at it's core, but made loads of sense. Sophie Brown was always right. It was a fact of life.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lizasaurus

No, he didn't agree, they aren't fascinating topics and definitely didn't have his curiosity nor did he want to explore them. He looked around for Jay knowing he probably felt the same way but didn't see him. Swallowing he didn't even raise his hand to answer like he normally would. Why would anyone want to even be curious about that. Unless of course they wanted to be a dark wizard?
Nope, he wouldn't ever do that. His first dad enjoyed it. But he didn't. No way!

There were quite a few students who elected not to give an answer. Some looked uncomfortable by the question and others appeared content to listen to their classmates answers. That was fine, and he tried to ignore the Auror-nagging that maybe one or two of them were hiding something.

Kids. Students. Nothing to be suspicious of. And, again, he had asked.

SPOILER!!: Unique Answers/Return Questions - replies within

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mordred

Ethan slowly raised a hand and answered the professor’s question. “Well, we don’t get the chance to learn it on a daily basis because that could drive us to the dark side,” Star Wars reference, yo. “And the fact that it seems to be taboo in any magical school, it makes us more curious as to what it can do, versus the things that we can do.” He wasn’t sure if his answer was satisfactory at all, but his point was somewhere in between those lines. “I hope you don’t mind me asking Professor, but...what pushed you to become an Auror?” His cousin did consider to become one, but decided not to.

This one got a grin, because Star Wars. Had he not been sitting at the front of the class, he would have high-fived the kid's raised hand.

Instead, he nodded in response to Mordaunt's answer. "Less time spent teaching Dark Magic, means more time learning about unique ways to defend against it."

And then there was that return question. Sabel's smile wavered a little. Bit personal for so early in the morning, wasn't it? But then, it was DADA and he was sure that Mordaunt wasn't the only one curious. Sabel let out a sigh. "Dark Wizards and Dark Magic. Threats to everything, and everyone I love."

He wouldn't go into detail about the Cult. He was sure more than one student's parents had read the Prophet and had raised concerns about his alleged association with them. Putting such words on children's ears could end very poorly in so many ways.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tegz

She processed the tail end of what she had heard and then stuck her hand up.
"Bad boys are hot, professor."
So. That was why.

Sabel nearly choked at the answer. So simple. So plain. So abrupt and straightforward. So......dangerous.

Merlin. What was it with teenagers? "They also expire a lot quicker, than good boys." For those that were interested in long lasting relationships.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hera

It was the kind of question he was sure Emily wanted an answer to, so it only confirmed his suspicions that Sabel would indeed be spying on him and taking notes too. He best make his answer super good then. SUPER good.
Hand raised, Zeke waited his turn to add his two knuts to the conversation.
"I don't think the dark arts are alluring at all, I think it's nasty horrible stuff that should be avoided like the plague death that it is and it is in no way a symbol of power or anything like that and in fact the people that use it are super weak and stupid and heartless horrible nasty people that should die." Ahem. Yeah. Stick that in your letter why don't you.

His laughter was contained and restrained only by the blank look that Zeke got. Was this the same child he had met over Christmas, or had the ghosts of past, present and future done a 180 on him?

He wasn't sure that he believed what the kid was saying, but he could appreciate the sentiment, a lot more than he liked. "Most of them are." And should. But it would do no good to advocate the death sentence in a classroom of students. "Everyone deserves a fair trial though."

There were, of course, extenuating circumstances...

Quote:

Originally Posted by PhoenixStar

Time to give her view on the subject. The lion raised her hand and waited to be called on. "For me personally, I'm intrigued because it's always considered bad and off limits and I want to know why? Is it really so black and white? I don't think so. Surely you can use some things that are considered dark for a good reason. And just because use used something that was deemed dark doesn't automatically make you a dark wizard. Plus, I'm just curious and like to test my limits. As soon as you tell me I can't or shouldn't do something it makes me want to prove you wrong and do it... just because." Really, she could go on and on, but she felt like she got her point across to some degree.

At first, Sabel found Valentine's answer rather philisophical and an echo of a lesson he participated in long ago. That was, until she went and concluded it by saying she would try what she was told not to. Just.....kids these days.

"Everything is a choice. The choice of whether to use dark or not. But, if you use dark for good, are you tainting the good?" A point to think on, for everyone. One that possibly didn't have an answer. It wasn't so long ago that he had thought everything had a black and white to it. He could certainly understand, at least the first part, of her answer.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cassirin

Why were people interested in the Dark Arts? Most people were going with the forbidden fruit angle, which made a lot of sense to Dot. Only... well, she thought there might be more than that. Her hand shot up. "Professor, I think maybe some people have the idea that using Dark Arts can get you to your goals faster than doing it the real way. I think people are always interested in looking at the easy route before they decide that it isn't worth the cost. 'Cept when they decide that it IS worth the cost."

There were some real thinkers in this class. Some real, determined thinkers.

"A very good point." He nodded solemly. "The Dark Arts can produce results very quickly and potently. It might take a bit longer, or a bit more ingenuity to get to the desired result using regular magic. But there is always a cost." And it was different for everyone.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tiro MacMhuirich

Listening to everyone else giving their answers, Marsha continued to think about it. Putting her hand up, she gave an answer that she thought was different enough to the others in her class. ”Sir, maybe they don’t really realise they are doing it, until its too late? Like they do one charm or spell or hex in a situation where it is needed and then they think since they have already done it once, using it again won’t matter… Or they are using it to start with in grey situations, where there is no wrong or right reason… It might be something like ripples in water, from rain Professor? A tiny drop of water, that becomes larger and larger as its actions and consequences get shown; which would then require more magic to try and get out of which could spiral?”
…. Did that even make sense?

An unnerving, but rather accurate assessment. He nodded at Hanover. "A good assessment as to the psychology of some Dark Arts users and Dark Wizards, Miss Hanover. Once one allows their boundaries to fall, or be breached, it is easier to make excuses or reasons to tear the other ones down. And that is one of the weapons of the Dark Arts, against its user."

Quote:

Originally Posted by Meizzner

Well whatever, Dante will just give an answer.
"Every Great Hero needs a Great Villain."

Another simple one answer, and again one he was less inclined to agree with. An eyebrow arched at the boy. "There are no such things as heroes or villains. Only men fighting to their own means and ends."

Perhaps too many comic books over the summer?

Quote:

Originally Posted by hermionesclone

Once he knew what he wanted to say, Grayson raised his hand in the air and said, "Where there's good, there's evil. You can't expect to live in a perfectly good world where nothing bad happens. That's freaking impossible." Yin and yang and all that. "Besides, the evil makes things interesting. Everything would be soooooo boring if it was all smiles and rainbows. The bad things add a bit of spice to life, you know? While it's great to find out about someone's good traits and whatnot, it's the bad ones I'm interested in. The secrets. The things that make them tick. It makes a person more interesting." 'Course!
Was he finished? No way. "I wouldn't use dark magic at first." He had morals, thank you very much. "But if someone or something threatens to hurt me or someone I care about, you can bet your galleons that I'm gonna defend myself and them, even if that means using dark magic. You have to protect yourself by any means necessary." Shrug.

This one....he was concerned about this one. Boring? Not at first? Merlin, kids these days. Weren't they supposed to be wrapped up in grades and friends and all the drama of young love? Would be easier, so much easier.

"I can assure you, Mr. Whitlock, that once you experience evil you will not hold it in such regard." Merlin forbid that day would ever come and the kid could keep his delusions. "As I said, there is always a choice. Hopefully, you would find a solution in exhausting all other options before you ever reached such a point of desperation."

Was that everyone then? Sabel paused a moment, looking out over the gathered students as he waited for another response and let their discussion sink in. Nothing? Time to move on then. "Thank you all for your honest answers and input. As I know the Dark Arts can be a touchy subject, both in rule of speaking and practicing, I want this to remain an open discussion. If you have any further questions, or would like to discuss these topics in more detail, come find me. I'll do my best."

Right then, onto fun stuff. A grin broke free and abruptly his otter patronus disappeared. "Today, I'm going to teach you a skill that many Dark Wizards cannot, and never will, perform. For some of them to even try, it could result in harm to themselves."

Any lights going off?

Clasping his hands lightly on his wand and resting it on his crossed legs, Sabel let his eyes wander to to each student in turn. "What can you tell me about Patronuses?"

Today, was that someday, Mr. Rehman.

------------------------------------------

OOC: Hey all! Sorry this is late. Work and RL >.O

I'll make another post in about 8-10 hours, and class will move forward in about 20-24 hours

05-17-2015, 05:43 AM	#77 (permalink)
Tazenhani DMLE & DoM Doxy Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 6,150 Hogwarts RPG Name: Amur Neverwinter Fourth Year	~ Rise and Rise Again, Until Lambs become Lions ~ SPOILER!!: Responses to Greetings - replies within Quote: Originally Posted by nicole black He had a moment of wanting to say something else, though he didn’t know what- but then the Professor spoke, his silvery Otter of a patronus was crawling over Damien’s shoulders and sitting on top of his head as if this was it’s natural nest. The Gryffindor chuckled with surprise, and did his best to reach up and try to itch the technically non-existing creature. The patronus had the desired effect, and Sabel was relieved to see that the boy's mood could turn about. Hopefully, it would be a small help in encouraging him into a better mood. He'd need it for the remainder of the class. Quote: Originally Posted by WeasleyGirl Hugo tilted his head to one side in confusion. He slightly opened his mouth to answer the professor. What's down? what was that? Adults and their answers. "I'll think about it..." He probably shouldn't have been having so much fun, but he really couldn't help it. "Let me know what you come up with. I'm curious too." Why ask a question, if you weren't expecting an answer, after all. Quote: Originally Posted by FearlessLeader19 And then it was on his head, where he couldn't see much but when it hit the floor, he said, "Patronuses are such fun.'' Well, Professor Sabel's was anyway. Speaking of which... "I'll hold you to that, Professor.'' With a happy grin, he sidled off. The boy got a knowing grin. "See that you do. I like to keep my promises." Quote: Originally Posted by kayquilz Looking up as Professor Dakest started speaking, she smiled and nodded. "Oh-yes, sir--just in a good mood today--" Merlin. Even professors had started noticing her good moods? She must have been really mopey before...hmph. But the weekend had been so GREAT. Sabel nodded with a return smile. "Good. I hope that this class doesn't disturb your mood." Because it would either go really well, or really poorly with bitter disappointment. He was, of course, hoping for the former. Quote: Originally Posted by feeheeheeny Sophie DID want to conjure her own patronus and let their otter and ferret scamper about the room together, but she had read the rules and knew better than to practice without permission. She could SEE the calculating in his eyes, too, and noted that he did not tell her she could do her own, so... she nodded back in silent understanding. She didn't FULLY catch onto his line of thinking yet, but she would. No big deal. She didn't need to show it off anyway. He did regret it, just a little bit, that he hadn't asked for a student demonstration. Perhaps at some point in time, he would. If it was applicable, if it would prove helpful. For now, he was simple grateful that Brown seemed to understand not only his initial consideration, but his reluctance to follow through with it as well. Quote: Originally Posted by fanficfanatict Hugh was NOT fine. He wasn't embarassed, as Hughbert's didn't get embarassed but he might have been flushed. In a taken off guard kind of way. But not embarrassed. He did not acknowledge Dakest's inquiry, yo. He sort of fumbled through a response of nonsensical words and then shut up. Nailed it. He was.....okay? Something of the sort. Sabel couldn't really catch what the boy had said, but he didn't seem to be limping or crying or anything of the sort so it was probably best to just let it go. At least the stares weren't still happening. Quote: Originally Posted by Mell "You're easily impressed Kettleburn." He could show her his Patronus if she wanted. It was better than the Professor's except that he hadn't quite managed to hold onto his Patronus for very long. And he was just about to tell her that too when he realised that the Professor was talking to them. Apparently the man didn't think that their gum trick was very cool. Not wanting to get a detention so early into the term, he immediately swallowed his piece of gum. Well, that was one way to make quick work of the gum. Didn't really help with the concern of a choking hazard, but the kid seemed to be maintaing breathing function, so he let it go. Warning had been recieved and abided by, he couldn't ask for more than that. "Thank you, Mr. Toussaint. Quote: Originally Posted by Expecto-Penguin As Kace greeted Professor Dakest, he smirked and knew he was going to bring up his career choices. He began to say, "I actually knew what I wanted to do. I mean I made an appointment with the Care of Magical Creatures teacher to discuss options. I realized I do love animals though." he shrugged and hoped it didn't sound too cheesy. A pleased, and admittedly somewhat relieved, smile took over. "Good for you. I hope your discussion helps you start off in the right direction." Sorry Rainey, one less for the ranks. SPOILER!!: Answers about Curiosity and Testing the Forbidden Quote: Originally Posted by Kaos.Doodles Without much hesitation Kyroh raised his hand. "People are often in interested in what they don't know or aren't allowed to know." He paused to yawn. " The more you make something off limits the more interested we get. It's like with the Dark Arts and Dark Magic. We're told it's bad and not to do it, and that's the problem." And his dad had never told him that before. Nope......Possibly. Quote: Originally Posted by WeasleyGirl Hugo tilted his head to one side in confusion. He slightly opened his mouth to answer the professor. What's down? what was that? Adults and their answers. "I'll think about it..." Class began and Hugo raised his hand to answer the first question. "Because of curiosity. Everyone tell us that dark magic and everything related to it is bad, so... he shrugged "I don't know. I like to know about stuff that are like 'forbidden', they are way more interesting to read about " and no, he wasn't planning on becoming a dark wizard. Quote: Originally Posted by fire_faerie "I think I agree with the curiosity for the unknown. It's dark, it's dangerous, we don't know much about it but we DO know that it is capable of far worse things than just killing," Benzi raised his hands, thinking while talking. "There's just something stupidly exhilarating about that... And, right, so learning about the dark arts and dark wizards themselves is fascinating in and of itself, but then learning that we can actually beat them? They're so good with magic, the dark arts are incredibly strong and potent, and then learning that we can counter that with good magic? I think that's the best part." Quote: Originally Posted by Harry174 Angel raised her hand. "Professor it's because you are told that they are dangerous and many people like children when they are told not to do something they have to try it so that they can see why they are told not too." Angel had a few stories she could tell the Professor but she would probably get into trouble for them. Quote: Originally Posted by GoldenSnake "Humans are naturally curious." Natalia gave a simple explanation, shrugging slightly afterwards to show her uncertainty of her own comment. It was understandable to her why wizards would like to discover more about dark magic: it was mysterious. Humans throughout history have tampered with the unknowns, the enigmas, the riddles, the secrets. For what reason? - that was among the most-asked questions. Natalia, being naturally curious herself, often asked herself these philosophical questions during her free time ~~(when she was not paying attention in class)~~. *"Or more accurately, it's a mixture of curiosity and self-benefit."* The Lioness added to her response. Quote: Originally Posted by ScarletCharm104 "Young people like to rebel, I guess. Do stuff that they're told not to do. REVERSE PSYCHOLOGY, that's it." Quote: Originally Posted by Daydreamer11 Finally she raised her hand and responded. "I agree with my classmates. The thing that you are forbidden to try is always the most tempting. It always seems way more glamorous than it really is when grown ups tell you not to bother with it. For me though, I always wonder what would make a person go to the dark side. Why would they do it?" Janelle wanted to know about the dark arts as a way to protect herself against it. Knowledge was power, at least that was what she believed. Merlin, so this was the group he had to watch out for. The ones that thought just because an adult said it was a bad idea, that it was actually a good idea. Problem was, it would take their own step into adulthood to wake them up from their preconcieved notions of adults being sticklers. He knew. He'd been a kid once too. Which was why, perhaps, he appreciated this line of answering more than most. It made sense. It was almost, expected, and in that way it was an innocent curiosity. Still... *"Have you ever heard the saying, curiosity kills the cat?"* Maybe that was a bad saying to start out with. Maybe people would take offence to the killing of cats. Or killing in general. He moved on quickly. "As a word of advice, in my experience, if someone has warned against dark magic, arts or wizards, there is a very good reason they have done so. Curiosity in and off itself is not a bad thing, but you have to be mindful of what consequences may come out of it. And where you get your answers to your curiosity from." SPOILER!!: Answers of What Drives Dark Wizards / Psychology Behind the Dark Arts Quote: Originally Posted by FearlessLeader19 Dark stuff? HECK YEAH! Adi found them REALLLLLY fascinating (maybe it was due to his taste in music) even though it sort of countered his bubbly personality. So what? He had been told more than once that he had a bit of Slytherin in him. The Hufflepuff raised his hand. "They are just fascinating. I know I am interested in that because I want to know what pushes people to become dark wizards and want to entangle themselves with dark magic. I think if we can get those answers, we could have less evil running around.'' Quote: Originally Posted by kayquilz "I think what I find most interesting is that...the bad guys...the dark wizards? They could be any of us...any one of us...if put through certain conditions and events and...upbringings...the monsters of humanity are never the ones we think...they always come from within. And this...is why it's so fascinating. Because deep down...we all have the capability." Ahem. What? Quote: Originally Posted by Jessiqua She wasn't sure if it was a call out your answer or raise your hand class, so she went formally and raised her hand anyway, waiting for an okay to speak. "Er, well I guess for me anyway, I'm intrigued about the darker side of magic because it's something I know I will never experience. Well I hope so anyway. I'd never see myself casting the unforgivable curses or duelling with anyone outside a classroom, so I suppose my mind wants the knowledge. For example, I'd never cast the cruciatus curse on anyone, and I hope it's never cast on me, but I'm interested in what reasons the caster has to cast it, and what it feels like on the victim. I suppose because I hope I never experience it I want to know about it." Did that make sense? She had a feeling she was rambling a bit and stopped, looking a bit self-conscious. Quote: Originally Posted by RandomRaven "I think because... They're just curious or maybe also had a background like... They're coming from dark wizard family and stuffs. Maybe." Jackson spoke up as he raised his hand. Quote: Originally Posted by Expecto-Penguin As Kace greeted [B]"Well Professor I think the dark arts are interesting because it is a topic some people would not necessarily study on their own. I mean some people would not necessarily study killing curses for fun. As for the history aspect though I find it interesting to know what other wizards have done. It makes me feel that they started out just like us. It is something we can relate to but I do like the concept of Harry Potters' history with Voldemort.." he said just thinking out loud. I mean it was on topic though. This group of students was a little more concerning, but it was a fresh take and an answer he hadn't really been expecting. Who had thought that young students would be so interested in the minds behind the Dark Arts and Dark Magic, that psychology was a question. A bit disconcerting. "I can't really give any testiment to sate your curiosity about the minds of Dark Wizards, except to say that it is best if you don't know them." That whole telling a student population not to do things? Right...maybe a bit more. "They are often complex and twisted, and can be so demented as to have you questioning your own morals and choices. There is a fine line between understanding, and pity. One will keep you safe, the other may put you in a very tricky spot." He wouldn't say that most Dark Wizards had sad stories or interesting pasts, because he was sure most of the students that had offered such an answer were likely to sympathize with them. And that was a recipe for disaster. SPOILER!!: Answers for Knowledge is Defence Quote: Originally Posted by Ginevra Cilla had always had this sort of question lingering in the back of her mind but she was having trouble conveying the right words. She slowly raised her hand. "I personally think that some knowledge of the dark arts would suffice. The theory aspects of it, of course. I mean, how can we defend ourselves against it if we know nothing about it?" Cilla hoped that Professor Dakest understood what she meant. Quote: Originally Posted by Squishy After a moment, she raised her hand. "I think a lot of people find this stuff fascinating because they don't really know much about it. Plus, it DOES serve as a good advantage to know the evils out there in order to protect yourself against them." That spoke for both dark magic AND dark creatures. Quote: Originally Posted by feeheeheeny But with a raised hand, she offered her own personalized version, "It's the unfamiliar, I think. I mean... MOST of us grow up without direct contact with Dark magic, if we're lucky. There's something enticing 'bout learning about things that scare us, things that can be threatening to us - it gives us a rush, y'know? S'like Muggles with their scary movies, 'cept this is real life for us. And we wanna learn 'bout them for... well, just general curiosity reasons, but also so we know what's out there - curiosity about the world at large, really, and potential dangers... and naturally we wanna learn about these things so we know how to protect ourselves from them. That's normal. S'just human nature to have those kinds of instincts, if y'ask me." . Quote: Originally Posted by Mell [COLOR="SeaGreen'"]He raised his hand to answer the question. "For me it's not curiosity or wanting to break rules, I NEED to know what's out there. What I will be up against when I head out into the real world. Knowledge of every aspect of magic has to be useful, right?" This, was the answer he still struggled with himself. The benefit of dark magic, of being curious about it and learning about it. And it was also the purpose of their class. Ironic. But at least he didn't have to worry too much about this group. Thinkers and rational with their interests. It would keep them evaluative and relatively safe. Hopefully some of the other students would pick up on similar mindsets. He nodded, his patronus walking around him slowly before stopping at his right side. "Very right you are. Hard to defend against something you know little about." But with that knowledge, came the temptation to use and practice. "Hopefully, these DADA classes will answer some of your questions and make you prepared for what you may encounter out there." SPOILER!!: Answers for Control and Power Quote: Originally Posted by nicole black Why? Why the fascination? That was a surprising question, Damien wasn’t sure if his answer would be exactly what Professor Dakest was looking for, but… “Because it doesn’t seem like it can really be controlled, and things that you can’t pin down are always more interesting than what you can.” Least, that was his thought. Quote: Originally Posted by PhoenixRising Raising her hand, she lowered before speaking, "In the words of the 35th American President, 'In a time of turbulence and change, it is more true than ever that knowledge is power', so basically, what this means is that the youth desire the knowledge not necessarily to use it, but because it means power. And to be frank, who doesn't like having authority?" See, there was a reason Ravenclaws were so into learning. These two students got a curious look. Did he have reason to be worried? It sounded like it. He shook his head, watching his patronus stretch out beside him. "Be careful not to confuse power, with a lack of responsibility and accountability. Those that are truly powerful, are those that can defend against the terrible, with restraint and gentleness." "I suppose then, we need to find a way to learn how regular magic can be just as, or more intriguing, than the Dark Magic." His attention slid to Mancini. "And, in many cases, more powerful. Hopefully, I can show you a bit of that today." SPOILER!!: Answers Against Interest and Intrigue Quote: Originally Posted by Felixir He raised his hand. "Maybe they're not. Maybe it's a misunderstanding and nobody actually likes that stuff." Maybe = definitely. But it didn't matter on account of it being fiction. YEP. Quote: Originally Posted by Sararara She put a hand in the air and waited to be called on because HER sense had a whole lot of stuff to say. "I don't think the dark arts are fascinating at all. Just scary because mean stuff is scary and everything I've heard about the dark arts seems pretty mean to me. Mean stuff is bad. I don't like mean stuff." Did he SEE how sure she was about this? Because she was really sure. The most sure, even. "I guess some other people could like hearing about them for the same reason people like scary stories and stuff, 'cause they think it's cool and different 'cept i don't like any of that so I don't think I'm the right person to answer this question." She put her hand and smiled, because it wasn't HIS fault that his question was incorrect. And even if it was incorrect people deserved lots of smiles too. She would know. Oh. So there were students who weren't gungho about Dark Magic this and Dark Magic that? Merlin either they were pulling his leg on account of asking such a question, or they were serious. He hoped for the later, and judging by some of the expressions, he was almost positive that was the case. He gave them both an understanding smile. *"No misunderstanding Mr. Fuller-Thompson."* He would make sure he got it right from now on, especially on account of the boy's reaction. *"I've met a good handful of young adults who are very* interested in such things." As were his classmates, but he had asked and he wouldn't berate them for answering. Kittredge got his soft smile next. "Your answer is just as valuable as everyone else's. The Dark Arts are called such because they can be very mean and scary. A good reason to show restraint and judgement in curiosity and learning." SPOILER!!*: The Silent Lot* Quote: Originally Posted by laurange Brian just blinked at the professor. He was asking why the Dark Arts were fascinating? Of course they were fascinating. They were fascinating because they were taboo, and telling a bunch of teenagers that something was taboo would just make them want to do it more, right? Teenage rebellion and all that. A lot of people were saying that, though, so Brian would just keep silent for now. He was satisfied to twirl his pen around, doing funny stunts with it to keep him awake. Early morning class, y'know? He had to keep the fingers awake because then the whole body woke up. But really. Forbidden fruit always tastes the sweetest. Quote: Originally Posted by Symphora Henric didn't know how to answer Professor Dakest. Why they were so intrigued with DADA?...He had no idea why but something about defending one self in times of danger was an important part of being a wizard, wasn't it? He learnt Judo at a young age so he knew that muggles not only used it for self-defence, it was also used to show off their skills in a duel...wasn't it the same thing too for wizards? Anyone could be a dark wizard if she/he had the skills to, and in order to prevent that from happening, we need good wizards to restore the balance. Quote: Originally Posted by SpiritWolfe Malfoy Only did Hady's attention shift when she heard the Professor began to speak. Very quickly hands were being raised around her...the same answers being said over and over. So really there wasn't much point in answering was there? Hady didn't think so which was why she kept quiet for now. Quote: Originally Posted by fanficfanatict ....he didn't answer the question though. Hugh was still struggling with the English language and it was probably for the best. He didn't have a point of view on an opinion question. Quote: Originally Posted by ArianaBlack When he heard Sophie's answer, he lifted his head and wore a big smile on his face. He liked her's the best. She was after all a GENIUS. Unfamiliarity made people curious. It was a simple answer at it's core, but made loads of sense. Sophie Brown was always right. It was a fact of life. Quote: Originally Posted by Lizasaurus No, he didn't agree, they aren't fascinating topics and definitely didn't have his curiosity nor did he want to explore them. He looked around for Jay knowing he probably felt the same way but didn't see him. Swallowing he didn't even raise his hand to answer like he normally would. Why would anyone want to even be curious about that. Unless of course they wanted to be a dark wizard? Nope, he wouldn't ever do that. His first dad enjoyed it. But he didn't. No way! There were quite a few students who elected not to give an answer. Some looked uncomfortable by the question and others appeared content to listen to their classmates answers. That was fine, and he tried to ignore the Auror-nagging that maybe one or two of them were hiding something. Kids. Students. Nothing to be suspicious of. And, again, he had asked. SPOILER!!: Unique Answers/Return Questions - replies within Quote: Originally Posted by Mordred Ethan slowly raised a hand and answered the professor’s question. “Well, we don’t get the chance to learn it on a daily basis because that could drive us to the dark side,” Star Wars reference, yo. “And the fact that it seems to be taboo in any magical school, it makes us more curious as to what it can do, versus the things that we can do.” He wasn’t sure if his answer was satisfactory at all, but his point was somewhere in between those lines. “I hope you don’t mind me asking Professor, but...what pushed you to become an Auror?” His cousin did consider to become one, but decided not to. This one got a grin, because Star Wars. Had he not been sitting at the front of the class, he would have high-fived the kid's raised hand. Instead, he nodded in response to Mordaunt's answer. "Less time spent teaching Dark Magic, means more time learning about unique ways to defend against it." And then there was that return question. Sabel's smile wavered a little. Bit personal for so early in the morning, wasn't it? But then, it was DADA and he was sure that Mordaunt wasn't the only one curious. Sabel let out a sigh. "Dark Wizards and Dark Magic. Threats to everything, and everyone I love." He wouldn't go into detail about the Cult. He was sure more than one student's parents had read the Prophet and had raised concerns about his alleged association with them. Putting such words on children's ears could end very poorly in so many ways. Quote: Originally Posted by Tegz She processed the tail end of what she had heard and then stuck her hand up. "Bad boys are hot, professor." So. That was why. Sabel nearly choked at the answer. So simple. So plain. So abrupt and straightforward. So......dangerous. Merlin. What was it with teenagers? "They also expire a lot quicker, than good boys." For those that were interested in long lasting relationships. Quote: Originally Posted by Hera It was the kind of question he was sure Emily wanted an answer to, so it only confirmed his suspicions that Sabel would indeed be spying on him and taking notes too. He best make his answer super good then. SUPER good. Hand raised, Zeke waited his turn to add his two knuts to the conversation. "I don't think the dark arts are alluring at all, I think it's nasty horrible stuff that should be avoided like the plague death that it is and it is in no way a symbol of power or anything like that and in fact the people that use it are super weak and stupid and heartless horrible nasty people that should die." Ahem. Yeah. Stick that in your letter why don't you. His laughter was contained and restrained only by the blank look that Zeke got. Was this the same child he had met over Christmas, or had the ghosts of past, present and future done a 180 on him? He wasn't sure that he believed what the kid was saying, but he could appreciate the sentiment, a lot more than he liked. "Most of them are." And should. But it would do no good to advocate the death sentence in a classroom of students. "Everyone deserves a fair trial though." There were, of course, extenuating circumstances... Quote: Originally Posted by PhoenixStar Time to give her view on the subject. The lion raised her hand and waited to be called on. "For me personally, I'm intrigued because it's always considered bad and off limits and I want to know why? Is it really so black and white? I don't think so. Surely you can use some things that are considered dark for a good reason. And just because use used something that was deemed dark doesn't automatically make you a dark wizard. Plus, I'm just curious and like to test my limits. As soon as you tell me I can't or shouldn't do something it makes me want to prove you wrong and do it... just because." Really, she could go on and on, but she felt like she got her point across to some degree. At first, Sabel found Valentine's answer rather philisophical and an echo of a lesson he participated in long ago. That was, until she went and concluded it by saying she would try what she was told not to. Just.....kids these days. "Everything is a choice. The choice of whether to use dark or not. But, if you use dark for good, are you tainting the good?" A point to think on, for everyone. One that possibly didn't have an answer. It wasn't so long ago that he had thought everything had a black and white to it. He could certainly understand, at least the first part, of her answer. Quote: Originally Posted by Cassirin Why were people interested in the Dark Arts? Most people were going with the forbidden fruit angle, which made a lot of sense to Dot. Only... well, she thought there might be more than that. Her hand shot up. "Professor, I think maybe some people have the idea that using Dark Arts can get you to your goals faster than doing it the real way. I think people are always interested in looking at the easy route before they decide that it isn't worth the cost. 'Cept when they decide that it IS worth the cost." There were some real thinkers in this class. Some real, determined thinkers. "A very good point." He nodded solemly. "The Dark Arts can produce results very quickly and potently. It might take a bit longer, or a bit more ingenuity to get to the desired result using regular magic. But there is always a cost." And it was different for everyone. Quote: Originally Posted by Tiro MacMhuirich Listening to everyone else giving their answers, Marsha continued to think about it. Putting her hand up, she gave an answer that she thought was different enough to the others in her class. ”Sir, maybe they don’t really realise they are doing it, until its too late? Like they do one charm or spell or hex in a situation where it is needed and then they think since they have already done it once, using it again won’t matter… Or they are using it to start with in grey situations, where there is no wrong or right reason… It might be something like ripples in water, from rain Professor? A tiny drop of water, that becomes larger and larger as its actions and consequences get shown; which would then require more magic to try and get out of which could spiral?” …. Did that even make sense? An unnerving, but rather accurate assessment. He nodded at Hanover. "A good assessment as to the psychology of some Dark Arts users and Dark Wizards, Miss Hanover. Once one allows their boundaries to fall, or be breached, it is easier to make excuses or reasons to tear the other ones down. And that is one of the weapons of the Dark Arts, against its user." Quote: Originally Posted by Meizzner Well whatever, Dante will just give an answer. "Every Great Hero needs a Great Villain." Another simple one answer, and again one he was less inclined to agree with. An eyebrow arched at the boy. "There are no such things as heroes or villains. Only men fighting to their own means and ends." Perhaps too many comic books over the summer? Quote: Originally Posted by hermionesclone Once he knew what he wanted to say, Grayson raised his hand in the air and said, "Where there's good, there's evil. You can't expect to live in a perfectly good world where nothing bad happens. That's freaking impossible." Yin and yang and all that. "Besides, the evil makes things interesting. Everything would be soooooo boring if it was all smiles and rainbows. The bad things add a bit of spice to life, you know? While it's great to find out about someone's good traits and whatnot, it's the bad ones I'm interested in. The secrets. The things that make them tick. It makes a person more interesting." 'Course! Was he finished? No way. "I wouldn't use dark magic at first." He had morals, thank you very much. "But if someone or something threatens to hurt me or someone I care about, you can bet your galleons that I'm gonna defend myself and them, even if that means using dark magic. You have to protect yourself by any means necessary." Shrug. This one....he was concerned about this one. Boring? Not at first? Merlin, kids these days. Weren't they supposed to be wrapped up in grades and friends and all the drama of young love? Would be easier, so much easier. "I can assure you, Mr. Whitlock, that once you experience evil you will not hold it in such regard." Merlin forbid that day would ever come and the kid could keep his delusions. "As I said, there is always a choice. Hopefully, you would find a solution in exhausting all other options before you ever reached such a point of desperation." Was that everyone then? Sabel paused a moment, looking out over the gathered students as he waited for another response and let their discussion sink in. Nothing? Time to move on then. "Thank you all for your honest answers and input. As I know the Dark Arts can be a touchy subject, both in rule of speaking and practicing, I want this to remain an open discussion. If you have any further questions, or would like to discuss these topics in more detail, come find me. I'll do my best." Right then, onto fun stuff. A grin broke free and abruptly his otter patronus disappeared. "Today, I'm going to teach you a skill that many Dark Wizards cannot, and never will, perform. For some of them to even try, it could result in harm to themselves." Any lights going off? Clasping his hands lightly on his wand and resting it on his crossed legs, Sabel let his eyes wander to to each student in turn. "What can you tell me about Patronuses?" Today, was that someday, Mr. Rehman. ------------------------------------------ OOC: Hey all! Sorry this is late. Work and RL >.O I'll make another post in about 8-10 hours, and class will move forward in about 20-24 hours __________________ I've got a fire for a heart._________________________________________________ I'm not scared of the dark._________________________________________ _______________________________________You've never seen it look so easy.