Quote:

Originally Posted by Lexers

"Well, what if you didn't have your wand? Or somebody had disarmed, uh, taken your wand away?" Lucas suggested, raising his hand cautiously. "Or.. what if you didn't know how to use your wand all that well. Like if you're.. young," he said, a little quieter. Because that was embarassing.

Hmmm. "Being able to use a Gandr or invoke the magic in runestones when you're too young is almost impossible. Considering there is a Gandr for each rune, I don't suppose carry all twenty four Gandrs with them at all times." He chuckled, "But nice try." Runic magic and Gandrs were more specific than that.

Quote:

Originally Posted by nanyjj

"Er, lots of grown up people have learnt 'wand' magic, it's part of the basic education, but some of them did not take Ancient Runes when they were at school, so they don't know runic magic." The little girl said out loud. "If someone used a spell on someone else, he would be able to block it out. But if you used runic magic, the other person might think you are er.. talking rubbish?" That last sentence jumped out of her mouth before it reached her brain, and the girl regretted saying it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by PhoenixStar

Still, she was going to take a jab at it nevertheless. "I think you could use it as an intimidation factor. If you start busting out with all kinds of ramblings it's got to scare off somebody especially if you use infuse another object with strength." Talking in tongues and making another object have strength would frighten people off right? She just hoped she was making sense.

Botros laughed once again. Talking rubbish, she said. It was alright, he'd heard worse. "You mean to take advantage of the general ignorance of runes and their Galdrs? That's quite impressive." He grinned, even though it wasn't something he'd label as legit rune usage. The girls didn't seem one of those who'd use rune knowledge to their advantage.

Quote:

Originally Posted by lemon

"When... you don't have a spell for something?" Merlin. Why would Botros call on West? It was obvious he knew Runes better than any of them and was going to give them a ridiculous question, one requiring actual thought, that she had no idea how to answer. Call on someone else now, professor?

"A lot of times, I guess if you work a couple of runes together, they can have the same outcome as a targeted spell. So if there isn't really an existing spell to apply to your situation, you could use a combination of runes to achieve your... goal or whatever." That didn't even really answer his question. Oh well. Bonus points for the girlfriend? Alice thought yes.

One of Botros' eyes squinted in deep thought and attempt to get something useful out of the little Captain. "So, let's say you're in need of a specific protection field and you're not good with charms, Algiz combined with another rune is what you seek." Yes, yes, he got this. "Very creative, yes."

Text Cut: protection people

Quote:

Originally Posted by Edward Penguin

He did think about the question and then listened to the other answers. He didn't hear what came to his mind so he raided his hand. I've read in some books that the use of runic inscriptions frightened away non-magic users. As well, when activated, the runes either provided protection or entry into some sort of chamber. it's what came to mind for Ian anyways. He liked the idea of protecting his room using runes.

Quote:

Originally Posted by FireboltAvis88

Sander listened as the Professor replied to all the answers provided and he quickly jotted them down in his journal. Then it was time for another student to pose a question. This time a Slytherin boy.

.....and his question was.... not as easy as the first one. But Sander decided to hazard a guess at the answer. He raised his hand and replied.

"Runic magic is longer lasting than regular spell magic. Like if you needed to protect yourself, you could carve out the rune Algiz, which is the rune for protection onto a small piece of stone or wood and make it into an amulet or pendant, and wear it. As long as you wear it, you're protected for life. Spell magic to protect you like the Shield Charm only lasts for as long as you can concentrate holding it up, or before the effects wear off."

So there it was for a longer lasting or permanent form of magic, Runic magic was better.

Quote:

Originally Posted by hermygirl

He pondered West's question, before slouching back down in to his chair again. "I'd say runes are well suited to sustained magic, which would take excess concentration when you'd be better focusing on something else. Sooooo..." he sought for an example, "Something like a basic shield for protection, when you could be using offensive spells. Or running away."

Quote:

Originally Posted by grangerfan8

The sixth year hardly answered questions herself, but she sorta had one for this and so leaned forward some to give a response. No hand up. "Protection. For your personal items, homes, or yourself. It can be more lasting than a spell. Such as the runes protecting Hogwarts. Or on your own homes, or even on your trunk." Yes, she had runes protecting her stuff. No stealing things and running around with them without loosing a few digits. "Used correctly they can bar virtually any intruder, and even curse them in the process if you add those type runes into the mix."

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bubbles

Raising her hand, she said -- in the same manner she had with the Head Boy, "For protection of a large piece of landscape." Her home for example. They didn't need to know that, though. "And...well, um, to protect others. Like, if you can't go where they are going an amulet with runes is sometimes the pick of choice to keep them safe." And some had even cooler attributes, but she didn't want to share that part. Bev could already feel her face flushing.

Protection again, security. "Yes, very true. So you can use runes for long-term protection. Yes."

Text Cut: Divination people

Quote:

Originally Posted by Govoni

"I think for Divination purposes."...because in instances of everything else, a quicker, more desired effect would be from a wand....i.e. healing, protection, and "blowing things up" like West had said. "...Doing all those spreads where it tells you about your past, present, and future, I suppose. I mean, that's not really something you can get from your wand. Also, with the self improvement, like you mentioned,...I'm not aware of any spells that could make you stronger, or smarter, or faster. Potions, sure...but not spells from a wand."

It was easy for her to answer this because she was speaking directly to West...and not worrying about anyone else. See? More comfortable.

"I think runes are more fullproof, too...or they would be in my case." Since she struggled with casting anything that wasn't a charm. "Spells are difficult for some people, where runes wouldn't be as much."

Quote:

Originally Posted by rosebub6200

"Well Runes can be used in divination, and that's better than spells because spells aren't really used in that field."
She sunk in her chair, she knew it was a bad answer.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Squishy

Errr, another question that was hard to answer because it involved a lot of thinking. Slowly Lux raised her hand and attempted an answer. "I suppose in Divination, since you don't really use wands to figure out what is in your past, present, and future. And I suppose maybe when a person doesn't have a wand or doesn't really know defensive magic." that one was for self-explanatory reasons. As to anything else, Lux had absolutely no idea.

A lot of elaboration with the Ravenclaw, Botros nodded and then pointed at the person who mentioned Divination before herself. "Yes, now this makes more sense. Divination in the rune spread sense, seeking advice from runes is not something you could do with a magical wand. Casting spells stays easier than arranging rune spells though. In my experience, the rune spells or charms require way too much time and focus. If you find runic spells are easier than the regular ones, then you're a born Rune mistress." He gave her an encouraging smile.

Quote:

Originally Posted by FearlessLeader19

"Any situation especially life threatening ones where someone is in trouble but they are not er good at defensive spells,'' the second year said, his hand in the air. Yep, there were runes for protection so he figured that answer would work.

The professor scratched his scalp. "If you're in a life threatening situation, I suggest you use your magical wand. Far more efficient and faster than invoking the required runes when you're scared or stressed out." Even Botros could barely cast a runic spell in a life-threatening situation. "Nice try, though!" The boy was obviously ambitious.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Talikins

Yeah she'd heard Alec and half listened to the answers, but really she wanted to hear other things. Could they not just have a lesson on fairies? Or best friends? Or something more interesting than anything in the past. Like WHO even used..well people did use Ancient Runes, but actually spoke it...nope nobody did.

Abbi could think of a few things to use Ancient Runes though and it was for that reason she raised her hand as the Slytherin Captain asked his question. "Can't you use it for curse breaking?" Or was that Arithmancy?

Aha! "Yes, definitely one of the usages of Runes. Why would you be in a situation where you're required to break a curse, though, dear?" Should he be concerned with the lifestyle of this little one? Botros just smiled at her.

Quote:

Originally Posted by hermionesclone

The hand went up. "Well... you could use it in situations where you need something stronger than a spell. I mean... last year, we activated the suits of armour by inscribing runes on them and then making them attack the other teams or defending our own teams. We had to use spells too, yeah, but... using the runic magic was better and caused more powerful results than just using the spells." ... Pause. "And it would have been stronger than using Piertotum Locomoter. I... think."

The other question? "As... for the situation and what makes it a better choice... what about the time? Maybe if you have enough time to prepare for... say, a battle and aren't being attacked out of the blue, you could use runic magic to help."

Had he answered the questions? He hoped so.

Oh yes, see, this was a great answer! Botros couldn't help but clap for the Head Boy. "Exactly, I believe this is what Mr. Odessa was aiming for. Rune magic isn't about getting something done in a timely manner or instead of something, it's a slow sort of magic that once invoked releases enormous amount of magical energy. Bigger results than magical spells, as you put it."

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lissy Longbottom

He raised his hand. "Well when you're putting out a fire, I think it'd be best to use your super powered runes spell to create a stronger water stream than Aguamenti. Especially if it's a large fire. Don't even bother with the weak spell - go big or go home," he explained. Yes, that situation TOTALLY called for runes magic, not regular magic.

The professor chuckled at the boy's last expression. The youth and their modern talk. "Strength, yes, runes give you bigger results. Use them when you're handling big situations." He repeated in another words, the boy got a few claps from the professor as well.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lady of Light

Interesting question.. and difficult but Delilah was determined to try. She hesitated for a second before raising her hand. "Um.. correctly carved runes powered with adequate magic are more stable and tend to stay longer as compared to spells from a wand.." Yes? Was she right? She looked at the boy for a second before turning her gaze towards the professor.

"For long-term purposes, yes, correct." Oh this new girl was getting in the zone quite quickly. Botros gave her an encouraging smile and a nod.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Saraie

"I think its a better choice just for the Simplicity of them. Who didn't like things simple? He did. "It doesn't take up as much time or energy in some cases. Plus there are tons more things that runes can do verses spells or charm."

Aaah, alas. "Runic charms and spells tend to be rather time-consuming, actually. Enormous energy but it takes time to be invoked." More time than their regular spell work. Mr. Odessa's question seemed to had puzzled a few of his peers.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Felixir

"What about luck?" Toby said, not quite tentatively but not quite full of confidence either. "I mean, we know that luck exists, and is something that can be boosted by magic, because there's potions for it. Felix something-or-other. But I've never heard of a spell that would make you lucky, and also that potion takes ages to brew and is meant to be super complicated." He'd read ahead, okay? "So that would make runic magic the better choice in this case; it's much more accessible." Tobias paused a moment, as if unsure whether or not to go ahead with his full answer, but just went for it. "There are so many runes that the textbook mentions bringing luck, especially with galdrs. I assume that if you look at the other properties if the runes that would help with specifics. Like luck in gaining wealth, which would probably be Fehu, or luck in exams, which I think'd be... Ansuz?"

Tobias was pretty sure he was supposed to be giving a very specific example, but this was all he could think of without repeating someone else. Plus, it didn't escape him that he was giving a bit of a catch-all answer. "I mean it's not necessarily actually making something happen, like it's not foolproof because it's only amplifying luck, not making anything 100% sure. And if you could get the lucky potion I don't know if that would be better. But... for people like me who are better at runic magic than at NEWT level and higher potions... the runes would be the way to go."

Botros clapped again, "I'm not sure about Mr. Odessa but I think your answer is a thoughtful one! Very good, yes. Runes do come in handy when you're in need of spiritual boost."

Quote:

Originally Posted by Presley Black

Gwen didn't know much yet about spells from wands or runic magic, so she supposed they simply had different purposes, right? She raised her hand tentatively. "You said that runic magic can be used to infuse something with strength. What about people? Wouldn't it be easier for them to simply carry a rune rather than try spells to increase their own strength? Or healing or something?" Runes could be used for healing, correct? She assumed that they were something like essential oils in that respect. Her mother sometimes used Lavender when Gwen couldn't sleep or was worried about something. But runes were magic, so they could have long-term effects, right?

Physical strength. "Yes, like Uruz. Though you'd want to keep invoking it, make sure the shape of the rune doesn't get ruined with time. But yes, you're right."

Quote:

Originally Posted by HazelStone101

Emma bit her lip nervously, now things were starting to get a bit harder to answer. "Well, um... I guess in situations like healing, it might be easier to have runes because some spells might not work as well as having a rune that catered to a specific healing or strength need?"

Healing with runes is easier? Again, Botros disagreed, he rubbed his chin. "Might want to check with our Healer." He chuckled. "It should be associated with spells, this way it'll give long-term healing. Might speed it up a little too." How did they think he still had his knees intact after an injury?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gabben

*Romulus knew the answer to this one! His grandfather had some amulets with runes on them back home.*
"The Vikings would make amulets with runes of protection, wisdom, fertility, and more carved on them. This can be used rather than wand magic because rune magic is stronger and can sometimes last longer."

Botros clapped for this boy too! "Yes, very good. Correct." No need for him to repeat what he'd explained.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaniDiNardo

"I truthfully can't think of a situation where I'd grab for a rune instead of my wand." Force of habit and all. She preferred her wand. "But I suppose if I needed something large blown up, a rune would be the preferred choice depending on the magnitude of the explosion needed on account of that kind of magic would take more out of a person while the rune would make it super easy." Okay not super easy but come on, it wasn't rocket science or anything confuzzling like that.

That was all she had.

The Gryffindor Prefect was an honest one. Botros respected that, he nodded vigorously though at her answer. Like he mentioned before, larger and bigger results? Go for runic magic. Hopefully this was just an example, not a plan.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rosa Chispa Princessa

Oichi was really getting into this lesson. She liked that the professor was getting so in depth in questions about runes so quickly. She knew that when it came time to start using them it was most likely gonna be intense but oh so rewarding. But now it was time to answer the current question. Oichi raised her hand and responded, "Well, it would be a good idea to call on runic magic to handle things that magic can't, like changing the weather using a protection rune, or changing you're future using a rune to make you're future better. These things are not concrete enough for a magic wand to handle".

Hmm. "You can't change your future, you can seek advice from runes, though. Yes." He gave her a smile and a nod.